Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Finding a lender · 9 min read

Local Bank vs. National Lender: Which Is Better for a Commercial Loan?

Short answer

A local bank is usually better for loans under a few million dollars, for properties with a story (some vacancy, a renovation, a first-time borrower) and for anyone who wants a decision from people who know the market. A national lender is usually better for larger loans on stabilized properties, when you want a long fixed rate, a 30-year payment schedule or a loan with no personal guarantee. Neither is better in general: the right one is the lender whose loan size, property type and terms match your deal.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What do local and national mean here?

A local bank is a community or regional bank, or a credit union, that takes deposits and lends in a limited area, often a few counties or one state. It keeps most of its commercial real estate loans on its own books and decides on them in its own credit committee.

A national lender lends across the country from a central platform. The group includes several different kinds of lender:

  • Large banks with commercial real estate teams in many states
  • Agency lenders, which make apartment loans and sell them to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac
  • CMBS lenders, which pool loans and sell them to bond investors (see CMBS loans explained)
  • Life insurance companies, which lend their own long-term money on high-quality properties
  • National non-bank lenders and debt funds, which make bridge and small-balance loans

The practical difference is where the loan goes after closing. A local bank holds it. Many national lenders sell it or fund it with investors' money, so they follow fixed program rules. Fixed rules bring better terms for deals that fit and a firm no for deals that do not. The full map of lender types is in types of commercial real estate lenders.

Local bank vs. national lender: side by side

FeatureLocal bankNational lender
Loan sizeSmall loans welcome, upper limit set by the bank's sizeOften a minimum, commonly $1 million or more, with a high ceiling
Fixed-rate periodCommonly 3 to 10 yearsCommonly 5 to 10 years, longer on some programs
Payment scheduleCommonly 20 to 25 yearsCommonly 25 to 30 years, sometimes interest-only
Personal guaranteeUsually requiredOften non-recourse on program loans
PrepaymentStep-down penalty, often negotiableStricter formulas such as yield maintenance or defeasance
FlexibilityCan approve exceptions for a good borrowerFollows program rules closely
Closing costsLower legal and report costsHigher legal and report costs

Two terms in the table need a plain definition. Non-recourse means that if the loan fails, the lender can take the property but not your other assets, with exceptions for things like fraud. Yield maintenance and defeasance are prepayment methods that make you cover the interest the lender loses when you pay off early, which can be expensive when rates have fallen. Both are covered in recourse vs. non-recourse loans and commercial loan prepayment penalties.

When is a local bank the better choice?

  • The loan is small. Below about $1 million, many national programs are closed to you or carry costs that make no sense for the size.
  • The property is not perfect yet. A building with a few empty units, short leases or a planned renovation can still be a good loan to a banker who knows the street.
  • You are new. A local bank can weigh your character, your business and your deposits. A program lender mostly checks boxes.
  • You may sell or refinance early. A step-down penalty that ends after a few years is far easier to live with than defeasance.
  • You need construction or renovation money. Local and regional banks are the main source for smaller construction loans.
  • You want one relationship. The same bank can provide a line of credit, the mortgage and your operating accounts.

The cost of a local bank is usually a personal guarantee, a shorter fixed period and a shorter payment schedule, which means higher payments and sometimes a smaller loan. The bank will also want your deposits. If you are choosing among local institutions, see bank vs. credit union for a commercial real estate loan.

When is a national lender the better choice?

  • The loan is large. A loan beyond what your local bank can hold needs a bigger balance sheet or an investor-funded program.
  • The property is stabilized. A full building with steady income fits program rules and earns their best terms.
  • You want no personal guarantee. Agency, CMBS and life company loans are usually non-recourse.
  • You want the rate fixed for a long time. Ten years or longer is standard on several national programs.
  • You want the most loan dollars. A 30-year payment schedule or a period of interest-only payments lowers the payment, which raises the loan the income supports.
  • You own in several states. One lender that works everywhere saves you from starting over in each market.

The cost is rigidity. The loan documents are long and mostly not negotiable, the lender may collect monthly reserves for taxes, insurance and repairs, and paying off early can be costly. After closing, your contact is often a loan servicer, a company that collects payments and handles requests, and getting approval for a change can be slow.

A worked example: two offers on the same building

Here is a hypothetical purchase with round numbers. You are buying a stabilized $4,000,000 retail center and receive two offers.

  • Local bank: $2,800,000 (70% of the price), five-year fixed rate, 25-year payment schedule, full personal guarantee, 1% fee, about $15,000 of legal and report costs.
  • National lender: $3,000,000 (75% of the price), ten-year fixed rate, 30-year payment schedule, non-recourse, 1% fee, about $40,000 of legal and report costs.
  1. Closing costs. Local bank: $28,000 fee + $15,000 = $43,000. National lender: $30,000 fee + $40,000 = $70,000. The national loan costs $27,000 more to close.
  2. Cash you bring. Local bank: $1,200,000 down + $43,000 = $1,243,000. National lender: $1,000,000 down + $70,000 = $1,070,000. The national loan needs $173,000 less cash.
  3. Risk you carry. With the bank, your personal assets stand behind $2,800,000. With the national lender they do not, apart from the standard exceptions.
  4. Freedom to leave. The bank loan can be paid off in year four for a small step-down fee. The national loan's prepayment formula could cost far more if rates have dropped.

If you plan to hold the center for ten years, the national loan wins on cash, risk and rate certainty. If you plan to re-lease the anchor space and sell in four years, the bank loan is the safer fit even though it needs more cash. The plan decides, not the lender's size. A method for lining up offers is in how to compare term sheets.

What should you ask each lender?

The same short set of questions sorts both kinds of lender quickly:

  1. Have you closed loans on this property type in this county, and at this loan size?
  2. What loan-to-value and debt service coverage ratio do you need? (Debt service coverage is the property's net income divided by the yearly loan payments.)
  3. Is the loan recourse, partial recourse or non-recourse?
  4. How long is the rate fixed, and what happens when that period ends?
  5. What is the prepayment penalty in each year?
  6. What reserves and deposit accounts do you require?
  7. Who approves the loan, and how long from application to closing?
  8. Who handles the loan and answers requests after closing?

The first question matters most. A lender that has made the same loan nearby gives faster, firmer answers to the other seven. You can check the answer against public loan records, as described in how to use public loan data to find the right lender.

Can you ask both at the same time?

Yes, and for loans of roughly $1 million to $10 million you usually should, because both groups compete in that range. Send the same package to two or three local banks or credit unions and one or two national lenders on the same day. The local offers show you how flexible the terms can get. The national offers show you how much loan and how little recourse the property can earn.

Many owners use both over the life of one property: a local bank loan to buy and improve the building, then a national non-recourse loan once it is full and steady. A commercial mortgage broker can run this process for a fee, which is worth considering when you do not know the national lenders..

Where CREaiD helps you find both

CREaiD is a lender search for commercial real estate loans built on public loan records, with more than 7,000 banks, credit unions, mortgage lenders, SBA lenders, private lenders and funds. In Find Lenders you pick the state, the kind of loan and the loan amount and see the lenders that made that kind of loan there, local and national in one list. The deal check shows your loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield, so you know which group your deal fits before you call. It has a free version.

Terms differ by lender and by deal, so confirm every term in writing with the lender and review the loan documents with your own counsel.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Local banks hold their loans and can make exceptions, which suits small loans, new borrowers and properties that are not yet stabilized.
  • National lenders follow program rules and offer larger loans, longer fixed rates, longer payment schedules and often no personal guarantee.
  • National loans usually cost more to close and more to pay off early.
  • Your holding plan decides: flexibility for a short hold, long fixed non-recourse debt for a long one.
  • Between about $1 million and $10 million, get offers from both groups on the same day.

Questions people ask

Is it easier to get a commercial loan from a local bank?

For small loans and first-time borrowers, usually yes. A local bank can consider your whole relationship and approve reasonable exceptions. For a large, fully leased property, a national program can be just as easy because the deal fits its rules.

Do national lenders offer lower rates than local banks?

Not always. National program loans on stabilized properties are often priced competitively for long fixed terms, while a local bank may price lower on a short fixed period to win your deposits. Compare offers with the same fixed period, and include fees and prepayment terms.

What is the smallest loan a national lender will make?

It depends on the program. Many set a minimum of about $1 million, and CMBS and life company lenders often want several million or more. Some national non-bank lenders focus on small-balance loans, usually at higher rates than a bank.

Will a local bank lend on a property in another state?

Most prefer properties inside their market, where they know values and can inspect the building. Some will follow a strong existing customer to another state. If the property is far from the bank, expect a no or a more careful review.

Can you get a non-recourse loan from a local bank?

Rarely. Local banks and credit unions almost always ask for a personal guarantee, though a strong borrower with a low loan-to-value can sometimes negotiate a limited one. Non-recourse loans come mainly from agency, CMBS and life company lenders.

Should you use a broker to reach national lenders?

It helps when you have no contacts there. Some national programs are reached mainly through approved lenders or correspondents, and a broker knows which ones fit your deal. If you already know the right lenders, going direct saves the fee.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free