
What recourse means in practice
Commercial property is usually owned by a single-purpose entity, and that entity is the borrower. Recourse is about who stands behind the entity. In a recourse loan, one or more people or companies sign a guaranty and promise to pay if the borrower does not.
A hypothetical example. A loan has a $6 million balance when it defaults. The lender forecloses and the property sells for $5 million. The $1 million shortfall is called a deficiency. Under a full recourse guaranty, the lender can seek that $1 million, plus interest and costs, from the guarantor's other assets. Under a non-recourse loan with no carve-out violation, the lender absorbs the loss and the guarantor owes nothing.
State law affects how this plays out. Some states limit deficiency judgments or set rules on how and when a lender can pursue a guarantor. Your attorney can tell you what applies where the property is located.
The range from full recourse to non-recourse
| Type | What the guarantor is liable for | Where it is common |
|---|---|---|
| Full recourse | The entire debt | Banks, credit unions, SBA loans, most construction loans |
| Partial recourse | A capped share or amount, sometimes shrinking over time | Banks on stronger deals, some bridge loans |
| Non-recourse with carve-outs | Only losses from listed acts, or the full debt after certain acts | CMBS, agency, HUD, life companies, many debt funds |
| Completion and carry guaranties | Finishing the project and paying carrying costs | Construction and heavy renovation loans |
Partial recourse often comes with a burn-off: the guaranty drops or ends when the property reaches a target, such as a certificate of occupancy, a level of leasing or a minimum DSCR. If a lender insists on recourse, a burn-off is often easier to win than full non-recourse.
The loan type usually decides the starting point. CMBS loans and agency multifamily loans are non-recourse by design, while construction loans from banks usually are not.
The carve-outs in a non-recourse loan
Non-recourse never means no guaranty. A person or entity with real net worth signs a carve-out guaranty, often called a bad-boy guaranty. It has two parts, and the difference between them is large.
Loss carve-outs make the guarantor liable for the lender's actual loss from a listed act. Typical items:
- Fraud or material misrepresentation.
- Misapplying rents, security deposits, insurance proceeds or condemnation awards.
- Physical waste of the property.
- Failing to pay property taxes or insurance when the property produced enough cash to do so.
- Environmental liabilities, usually under a separate indemnity that can outlast the loan.
Full-recourse triggers make the guarantor liable for the whole loan. Typical items are a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the borrower, an unapproved sale or transfer of the property or of ownership interests, placing unpermitted debt or liens on the property, and breaking the single-purpose entity covenants.
What to negotiate
The time to negotiate carve-outs is at the term sheet, before you pay a deposit. Standardized programs leave little room, but balance-sheet lenders often have some.
- Limit full-recourse triggers to deliberate acts within your control, and move everything else to the loss category.
- Tie loss carve-outs to the lender's actual damages, not to the loan balance.
- Make sure that the property simply running short of cash is not a trigger by itself.
- Ask for notice and a chance to cure for technical breaches, such as a late financial report or a small mechanic's lien.
- For recourse loans, ask for a cap, a burn-off tied to clear milestones, or both.
- Check which transfers are permitted without consent, such as estate planning transfers or changes among existing partners.
Recourse terms belong in any side-by-side comparison of offers. How to compare term sheets shows where they fit with rate, proceeds and fees.
Who signs and what lenders check
Lenders want a guarantor whose promise is worth something. Whether the guaranty is full or carve-out only, expect these requirements.
- Net worth and liquidity: minimum levels set in the loan documents, often tested every year for the life of the loan.
- Financial statements: a personal or corporate statement at application and annually, with a schedule of real estate owned.
- Contingent liabilities: a list of the other guaranties the person has signed. Lenders add these up when they judge capacity.
- Joint and several liability: when several people guarantee, the lender can usually pursue any one of them for the full amount. Partners often sign a separate agreement among themselves to share the burden.
- Replacement rules: conditions for substituting a guarantor if a partner leaves, dies or sells an interest.
If you raise money from passive investors, tell them who is signing. The guarantor carries a risk the other investors do not, and many sponsors are paid a fee or a larger share of profits for it.
Which one should you choose?
Recourse is a price like any other. A lender that has a guaranty often offers a lower rate, more proceeds, fewer reserves or more flexible terms than it would without one. Non-recourse debt protects your other assets but usually comes with more structure and stiffer prepayment terms.
- Lean toward non-recourse when the property is stabilized, the loan is large compared with your net worth, you have outside investors, or you hold many properties and do not want one problem to spread.
- Accept recourse when the deal is small, the loan-to-value is low, the plan is short, or the property is in transition and non-recourse lenders will not quote. A bridge loan on a heavy renovation is a common case.
- Look at partial recourse when the lender's concern is one specific risk, such as lease-up, that will pass.
A guaranty is a personal legal obligation. Confirm the exact terms with the lender and have your own counsel review the guaranty before you sign.
Where CREaiD helps
Recourse policy differs by lender type. Types of commercial real estate lenders gives the general pattern.
For a specific deal, CREaiD's Lender Matchmaker lets you describe what you need and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders: banks, credit unions, agency lenders, private lenders, hard money and private equity. It has a free version.
Key takeaways
- Recourse lets the lender reach the guarantor's other assets; non-recourse limits the lender to the property, with carve-outs.
- Every non-recourse loan still has a carve-out guaranty with loss items and full-recourse triggers.
- Banks, SBA and construction lenders usually want recourse, while CMBS, agency, HUD and life company loans are typically non-recourse.
- Caps, burn-offs and the wording of the triggers are negotiable with many lenders, and the term sheet is the time to ask.
Questions people ask
Is a non-recourse loan really non-recourse?
For an ordinary default caused by the property losing income or value, yes. The lender takes the property and cannot pursue the guarantor. The guarantor remains liable for the listed carve-outs, and certain acts, such as a voluntary bankruptcy filing or an unapproved transfer, can make the whole loan recourse.
What is a bad-boy guaranty?
It is the common name for the carve-out guaranty in a non-recourse loan. It makes the guarantor responsible for losses caused by specific misconduct, such as fraud or diverting rents. It exists to discourage acts that damage the lender's collateral.
Can a recourse loan become non-recourse later?
Yes, if the documents include a burn-off. The guaranty reduces or ends when the property meets set tests, commonly completion of construction, a leasing level or a minimum DSCR. Get the tests written precisely so there is no argument about whether they were met.
Does non-recourse debt cost more?
Often it does in some form. The cost may show up as a higher rate, lower proceeds, more reserves, cash management or tighter prepayment terms. Compare complete offers, because a recourse bank loan and a non-recourse loan rarely differ in only one term.
Can the lender go after my personal assets under a recourse loan?
If you signed a full personal guaranty and the property does not cover the debt, the lender can generally seek a judgment against you. What it can actually collect depends on state law and on which assets are protected. Ask your attorney before you sign, not after a default.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
