Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Loan types · 7 min read

CMBS Loans Explained

Short answer

A CMBS loan, also called a conduit loan, is a fixed-rate commercial mortgage that the lender pools with other loans and sells to investors as bonds. For borrowers it usually means a 5- or 10-year term, non-recourse debt and competitive proceeds on stabilized income property. The trade-off is rigidity: prepayment is expensive, and after closing you deal with a servicer, not the lender who made the loan.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

How a CMBS loan works

CMBS stands for commercial mortgage-backed securities. A lender originates your loan, combines it with many others in a trust, and the trust issues bonds to investors. Your monthly payments flow through to the bondholders. The lender that closed your loan no longer owns it.

  • Originator: underwrites and closes the loan, then sells it into a pool.
  • Master servicer: collects payments, holds reserves and handles routine requests after closing.
  • Special servicer: takes over if the loan defaults or is close to default, and decides on workouts, extensions or foreclosure.
  • Bondholders: the investors whose interests the servicers must protect.

The servicers act under a contract that limits what they can agree to. That is why CMBS loan documents are standardized and why changes after closing are slow, costly or not possible. Plan for the loan you sign, not for the loan you hope to renegotiate.

Typical CMBS loan terms

TermTypical range
Loan term5 or 10 years, fixed rate, with a balloon at maturity
AmortizationCommonly 30 years; interest-only for part or all of the term on stronger deals
Loan-to-valueCommonly up to about 75%, lower for hotels and other riskier property types
DSCRCommonly 1.25x or higher
RecourseNon-recourse with standard carve-outs
PrepaymentDefeasance or yield maintenance, open only in the last few months
AssumptionAllowed with servicer approval and a fee

CMBS lenders finance most income-producing property types: office, retail, industrial, multifamily, hotels, self-storage, mixed-use and manufactured housing communities. Loans are usually at least a few million dollars, because the fixed legal and closing costs are heavy on a small loan.

The rate is a spread over a benchmark such as swaps or Treasuries, and it is normally set shortly before closing. Until the rate is locked, both the benchmark and the spread can move.

How CMBS lenders size the loan

A conduit lender runs three tests and gives you the smallest result: loan-to-value, DSCR and debt yield. CMBS lenders lean on debt yield more than most, because it ignores the interest rate and the amortization schedule.

A hypothetical example: the lender underwrites $1,000,000 of net cash flow and the appraisal comes in at $14 million. At 75% loan-to-value the loan could be $10.5 million. If the lender wants at least a 9% debt yield, the cap is about $11.1 million ($1,000,000 divided by 0.09). At a 1.25x DSCR, annual debt service can be up to $800,000. If payments on $10.5 million come in under $800,000, loan-to-value is the binding test and the loan is $10.5 million.

Note that the income is the lender's number, not yours. CMBS underwriting starts with NOI, then subtracts replacement reserves and, for office, retail and industrial, an allowance for tenant improvements and leasing commissions. It also applies a minimum vacancy and a management fee even if you self-manage. How lenders calculate NOI shows the usual adjustments.

The structure you sign up for

The price of non-recourse, fixed-rate money is structure. Expect most of the following.

  • Single-purpose borrower: the borrower must be an entity that owns only this property and has no other debts or business. Larger loans may also require an independent director and extra legal opinions.
  • Reserves: monthly deposits for taxes, insurance and replacement reserves, plus leasing reserves on office and retail.
  • Cash management: rents may go to a lockbox account. If DSCR drops below a trigger, or a major tenant leaves or does not renew, excess cash can be trapped by the lender until the problem is cured.
  • No extra debt on the property: second mortgages are generally prohibited. Mezzanine debt is sometimes allowed if it is arranged up front. See mezzanine debt vs. preferred equity.
  • Carve-out guaranty: a person or entity guarantees losses from specific bad acts, and some acts make the whole loan recourse. Recourse vs. non-recourse loans explains the list.

Read the cash management triggers with your leases in hand. A loan can be fully current and still go into a cash sweep because an anchor tenant gave notice.

Prepayment, assumption and maturity

You generally cannot simply pay off a CMBS loan early. The two usual methods are defeasance, where you buy a portfolio of government securities that replaces the property as collateral and makes the remaining payments, and yield maintenance, where you pay a penalty that makes investors whole for lost interest. Both are expensive when market rates are below your loan rate and cheaper when rates have risen. Defeasance is also typically locked out for about the first two years after the loan is securitized. Details are in the guide to prepayment penalties.

Because prepayment is costly, CMBS loans are built to be assumed. A buyer can take over the loan with servicer approval, an assumption fee (commonly around 1% of the balance) and legal costs. Approval takes time, so build it into the sale contract.

At maturity the remaining balance is due in full. If the property's income or value has slipped, the refinance may not cover the balloon, and extensions are handled by the special servicer on its terms.

When a CMBS loan fits and when it does not

CMBS tends to fit when:

  • The property is stabilized and you plan to hold it for the full term.
  • You want non-recourse debt and higher proceeds than a bank or life company offers.
  • The property type or market is one that banks and life companies pass on, such as a hotel or a smaller market.
  • The leases are long and the rent roll is unlikely to change much.

It is a poor fit when you expect to sell or refinance early, need future funding for renovations, plan major re-tenanting or redevelopment, or want a lender you can call for a quick consent. Value-add deals usually start with a bridge loan and move to permanent debt later. Terms vary by lender and pool, so confirm them with the lender and your own counsel before you sign an application.

Where CREaiD helps

Not every lender offers conduit loans, and those that do have their own minimum sizes and property preferences, so a short list saves time.

CREaiD's Lender Matchmaker lets you describe the deal and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders. You can also upload deal data for a quick investment analysis, which helps you see the numbers before a lender does.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • A CMBS loan is a fixed-rate, non-recourse loan that is pooled and sold to bond investors.
  • Lenders size it by loan-to-value, DSCR and debt yield, and the smallest result wins.
  • After closing you work with a master servicer, and with a special servicer if the loan gets into trouble.
  • Prepayment is by defeasance or yield maintenance, so the loan suits long holds on stabilized property.
  • Lockboxes, reserves and cash sweep triggers are part of the deal and should be read against your leases.

Questions people ask

Why is it called a conduit loan?

The lender acts as a conduit. It makes the loan intending to pass it into a securitized pool instead of keeping it on its own balance sheet. The terms conduit loan and CMBS loan are used for the same product.

Can I pay off a CMBS loan early?

Usually only through defeasance or yield maintenance, and not during an initial lockout period. Most loans become open to prepayment without penalty only in the last few months before maturity. If you expect to sell during the term, plan on the buyer assuming the loan or budget for the prepayment cost.

Are CMBS loans really non-recourse?

Yes, with exceptions. The lender's remedy for a normal default is the property, not your other assets. A guarantor is still liable for losses from listed bad acts such as fraud or misuse of rents, and events like a voluntary bankruptcy filing can make the full loan recourse.

Who do I call after closing?

The master servicer handles payments, reserve draws and routine requests such as lease approvals. Larger requests may need approval from the special servicer or other parties, which adds time and fees. If the loan defaults or is transferred for a likely default, the special servicer takes over.

How long does a CMBS loan take to close?

It often takes around two to three months from a signed application. The timeline is driven by third-party reports, legal work on the borrower structure and lease review. A complete, organized package at the start is the best way to keep it on schedule.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free