
What NOI includes and what it leaves out
The basic formula is NOI = effective gross income - operating expenses. Effective gross income is the rent the property could collect, less vacancy and credit loss, plus other income such as parking, laundry, storage or expense reimbursements from tenants.
Operating expenses are the costs of running the property: real estate taxes, insurance, utilities, repairs and maintenance, payroll, management, and general and administrative costs. Several items that reduce your bank balance are not operating expenses and stay out of NOI:
- Loan payments, both principal and interest
- Depreciation and amortization
- Income taxes
- Major capital projects, such as a new roof (though lenders add an annual reserve for them)
- Owner-level costs, such as asset management fees paid to yourself
For office, retail and industrial properties, many lenders go one step below NOI to net cash flow, which also subtracts an allowance for tenant improvements and leasing commissions. Ask which figure a lender sizes on.
How lenders adjust income
A lender wants income it can count on for the life of the loan, so it starts from documents, not from a pro forma. The main sources are the current rent roll and the trailing twelve months of operations, covered in how lenders read a rent roll and a T-12.
- In-place rents, not projected rents. Leases that are signed and paying count. Planned increases generally do not, except on bridge loans where the plan is the point.
- A minimum vacancy. Lenders commonly apply the higher of actual vacancy, market vacancy and a floor, often about 5% for multifamily and more for other property types. A fully leased building is still underwritten with some vacancy.
- Credit loss and concessions. Unpaid rent and free-rent periods come out of income.
- Above-market rents marked down. If a tenant pays well above market, the lender may count only market rent, because the lease will not renew at that level.
- Other income capped at history. Fee and ancillary income is usually limited to what the trailing period shows.
How lenders adjust expenses
On the expense side, the lender asks what it would cost a typical owner to run the building, including an owner who took it over after a foreclosure. That changes several lines.
- Management fee. Added at a market rate, commonly about 3% to 5% of effective gross income, even if you manage it yourself for free.
- Replacement reserves. An annual allowance for future capital work, commonly a few hundred dollars per apartment unit or a per-square-foot amount for commercial space.
- Real estate taxes. Reset to the expected bill after the sale if your state reassesses on a transfer. This is one of the largest and most often missed adjustments.
- Insurance. Underwritten at a current quote, not last year's premium.
- Repairs, payroll and utilities. Compared with similar properties. If your figure looks too low, the lender raises it to a normal level.
- One-time items. Removed when you can document that they will not repeat, such as a lawsuit settlement or storm cleanup.
A worked example: seller's NOI versus lender's NOI
Say a 100-unit apartment property has gross potential rent of $1,000,000. The seller's package shows 3% vacancy, no management fee because the seller self-manages, and no reserves. The lender uses 5% vacancy, a 4% management fee, reserves of $250 per unit, a reassessed tax bill and a new insurance quote.
| Line | Seller | Lender |
|---|---|---|
| Gross potential rent | $1,000,000 | $1,000,000 |
| Vacancy and credit loss | ($30,000) | ($50,000) |
| Other income | $40,000 | $40,000 |
| Effective gross income | $1,010,000 | $990,000 |
| Operating expenses | ($340,000) | ($444,600) |
| NOI | $670,000 | $545,400 |
The expense lines behind those totals:
- Real estate taxes: seller $120,000, lender $150,000 after reassessment
- Insurance: seller $40,000, lender $50,000
- Repairs, payroll and utilities: $180,000 in both
- Management: seller $0, lender 4% of $990,000 = $39,600
- Replacement reserves: seller $0, lender 100 units x $250 = $25,000
The lender's NOI is $124,600 lower, a cut of almost 19%, without the lender disputing a single rent. At a 1.25x coverage requirement, the debt service the property can support falls from $536,000 ($670,000 / 1.25) to $436,320 ($545,400 / 1.25).
Why the difference matters so much
Underwritten NOI feeds every sizing test at once. It is the numerator in DSCR and in debt yield, and it is the figure the appraiser capitalizes to reach value, as explained in cap rates and how lenders use them. A lower NOI therefore reduces the loan under all three tests together.
It also means the fastest way to predict your loan amount is to underwrite the property the way a lender will before you make an offer. If you size your purchase on the seller's NOI, you will find the gap during loan approval, when it is expensive to fix.
How to present your NOI to a lender
- Send clean source documents. A current rent roll, a month-by-month T-12 and the prior two or three years of statements.
- Show your own adjusted NOI. Add the management fee and reserves yourself. It signals that you know how underwriting works and removes a surprise.
- Explain every unusual line. Write a short note for each one-time expense, each rent concession and any large swing between months.
- Estimate the new tax bill. Call the assessor or a tax consultant and put the post-sale figure in your numbers.
- Attach proof. Leases, insurance quotes and tax notices carry more weight than a spreadsheet.
These documents belong in your commercial loan request package, and the result feeds straight into how to size a commercial loan.
Where CREaiD helps
CREaiD is an AI assistant for commercial real estate financing, built for investors and mortgage brokers. You can upload deal data for a quick investment analysis before you send the package out, then use the Lender Matchmaker to describe the deal and get lenders that fit.
Each lender has its own underwriting standards, so confirm the adjustments and terms with the lender and your own counsel.
Key takeaways
- Underwritten NOI is effective gross income minus operating expenses, on the lender's assumptions.
- Lenders add a vacancy floor, a management fee and replacement reserves even if you do not incur them.
- Reassessed real estate taxes are one of the largest and most often missed adjustments.
- A lower underwritten NOI reduces the loan under DSCR, debt yield and LTV all at once.
Questions people ask
Why is the lender's NOI lower than the one in the offering memorandum?
The seller's figure is built to show the property at its best, often with low vacancy, no management fee and no reserves. The lender adds normal costs that any owner would face and uses income it can document. The gap is expected, and you should plan for it.
Are capital expenditures part of NOI?
Actual capital projects are not operating expenses and stay below the NOI line. Lenders still deduct an annual replacement reserve when they underwrite, so some allowance for capital work does reduce the NOI they use. Ask whether a quoted NOI is before or after reserves.
Does a lender use trailing or projected NOI?
Permanent lenders rely mainly on trailing income, often the last twelve months for expenses and the last few months, annualized, for income that is rising. Bridge and construction lenders also underwrite a projected, stabilized NOI because the property is expected to change.
What is the difference between NOI and net cash flow?
Net cash flow is NOI minus replacement reserves and, for commercial properties, an allowance for tenant improvements and leasing commissions. CMBS lenders in particular size loans on net cash flow. It is always lower than NOI.
Can I count rent increases I plan to make?
Generally not for a permanent loan, where the lender wants income that is already being collected. Planned increases can be part of a bridge loan's business plan if they are supported by market rents and a renovation budget.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
