Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Underwriting and numbers · 7 min read

Cap Rates and How Lenders Use Them

Short answer

A cap rate is a property's net operating income divided by its value. Lenders use it in the other direction: they divide NOI by a cap rate to estimate what the property is worth, then lend a percentage of that value. A higher cap rate means a lower value and a smaller loan, so the cap rate a lender chooses matters as much as the loan-to-value it offers.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What a cap rate is

The formula is cap rate = NOI / value. If a building sells for $8,000,000 and produces $480,000 of net operating income, it sold at a 6% cap rate ($480,000 / $8,000,000).

Rearranged, the same formula gives value: value = NOI / cap rate. This is called direct capitalization, and it is the main way appraisers and lenders value an income property. The cap rate stands for the return a buyer would accept on that kind of property, in that location, with that risk. Safer income sells at lower cap rates. Riskier income sells at higher ones.

A cap rate says nothing about financing. It is the return on the property as if you paid all cash. That is why two investors with different loans can agree on the cap rate and still earn very different returns on their equity.

How a change in cap rate moves your loan

Because the cap rate sits in the denominator, small changes produce large swings in value. Take the same $480,000 of NOI and a lender that offers 70% loan-to-value.

Cap rateValueLoan at 70% LTV
6.0%$8,000,000$5,600,000
7.5%$6,400,000$4,480,000
8.0%$6,000,000$4,200,000

The income did not change at all. Moving the cap rate from 6.0% to 7.5% removed $1,600,000 of value and $1,120,000 of loan proceeds. On a purchase, that difference comes out of your pocket as extra equity. On a refinance, it can mean the new loan no longer pays off the old one.

The value test is one of several. See LTV vs. LTC for how the loan-to-value limit is applied and which value it uses.

Where the lender's cap rate comes from

You do not get to pick the cap rate, and neither, strictly, does the loan officer. It comes from a few sources:

  • The appraisal. A third-party appraiser derives a cap rate from recent sales of comparable properties, investor surveys and the property's own risk, then applies it to the appraiser's estimate of NOI.
  • The lender's own review. Credit staff check the appraiser's cap rate against deals the lender has seen and can cut the value they are willing to rely on.
  • An underwriting floor. Some lenders will not value a property below a minimum cap rate for its type, even if recent sales were lower. This protects them when prices are at a peak.
  • The purchase price. On an acquisition, most lenders use the lower of price and appraised value, so the cap rate you paid sets a ceiling on value.

Both inputs are the lender's. The NOI being capitalized is the underwritten figure after the lender's vacancy, management and reserve adjustments, described in how lenders calculate NOI. A lower NOI and a higher cap rate together can move value much further than either does alone.

The exit cap rate and the refinance test

On bridge and construction loans, the lender is repaid by a sale or a refinance a few years out. So it asks what the property will be worth then, using an exit cap rate (also called a terminal or reversion cap rate). Lenders usually set the exit cap rate above the going-in cap rate, to allow for an older building and the chance that the market is weaker when the loan comes due.

Say you ask for a $5,000,000 bridge loan and project stabilized NOI of $480,000. Your model uses a 6% exit cap rate, which gives a value of $8,000,000 and a loan equal to 62.5% of it ($5,000,000 / $8,000,000). The lender uses 7.5%. Its value is $6,400,000, and the same loan is now about 78% of value ($5,000,000 / $6,400,000 = 78.1%). A permanent lender that tops out at 70% would refinance only $4,480,000, which leaves a $520,000 gap. The bridge lender may respond by cutting its loan, asking for more equity, or passing.

If your plan depends on a refinance, run this test yourself before you apply. The guide to commercial bridge loans explains how lenders judge the exit.

Cap rate versus the cost of debt

Compare the cap rate you are paying with the loan constant, which is annual debt service divided by the loan amount. If the property yields less than the debt costs, borrowing lowers your cash return instead of raising it.

Using the same building: you pay $8,000,000 at a 6% cap rate and borrow $5,600,000. Suppose annual debt service is 7% of the loan amount, or $392,000. Cash flow after debt service is $480,000 - $392,000 = $88,000 on $2,400,000 of equity, a 3.7% cash return. Paying all cash would have earned 6%. The deal can still make sense if you expect to raise NOI, but the lender will notice the thin cash flow too: DSCR here is $480,000 / $392,000 = 1.22x. The guide to DSCR covers the minimums lenders set.

What you can do about it

  1. Bring your own comparable sales. Give the lender and the appraiser recent sales of similar properties nearby, with prices and NOI. Appraisers can only use the evidence they find.
  2. Stress your own model. Rerun the numbers with a cap rate 0.5 to 1.0 percentage point higher than you expect. If the deal breaks, the lender will see that too.
  3. Work on NOI. You cannot control the market cap rate, but each extra dollar of documented NOI is multiplied when it is capitalized. At a 7.5% cap rate, $30,000 more NOI adds $400,000 of value.
  4. Know the market's direction. Cap rates by property type and location shift with interest rates and investor demand. Check them before you set a price or a refinance target.

Once you have a defensible value and NOI, how to size a commercial loan shows how the value test combines with the income tests.

Where CREaiD helps

CREaiD is an AI assistant for commercial real estate financing. Its Insights tool provides current debt financing market insights by location and asset type, which is useful context when you set your assumptions. You can also upload deal data for a quick investment analysis.

Valuation methods differ by lender and appraiser, so confirm the terms with the lender and your own counsel before relying on any estimate.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Cap rate is NOI divided by value, and lenders use it to turn income into a value they can lend against.
  • A higher cap rate produces a lower value and a smaller loan from the same income.
  • The lender's cap rate comes from the appraisal, its own review and sometimes an underwriting floor.
  • Bridge and construction lenders test the exit with a cap rate higher than the going-in rate.

Questions people ask

Is a higher or lower cap rate better?

It depends on which side you are on. A buyer gets more income per dollar of price at a higher cap rate, while an owner's property is worth more at a lower one. For borrowing, a lower lender cap rate means a higher value and more loan proceeds.

What is the difference between a going-in cap rate and an exit cap rate?

The going-in cap rate is the first-year NOI divided by the price you pay. The exit cap rate is the rate assumed for the sale or refinance at the end of the hold. Lenders usually assume the exit rate is higher, which is the conservative choice.

Do lenders use the cap rate from my purchase?

They consider it, because a real sale is strong evidence. They still order an appraisal and use the lower of the price and the appraised value. If you paid a very low cap rate, the lender may also apply its own floor.

Does the cap rate include my mortgage payment?

No. NOI is measured before debt service, so the cap rate is the same whatever loan you put on the property. To see the effect of financing, look at DSCR and your cash-on-cash return.

Why do cap rates move with interest rates?

Buyers compare property yields with what they could earn on bonds and with what debt costs. When borrowing gets more expensive, buyers generally need a higher yield to make a deal work, which pushes cap rates up and values down. The link is real but loose, because rent growth and investor demand also play a part.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free