
Why life insurers lend on real estate
A life insurer collects premiums now and pays claims many years later. It needs investments that pay steady income over a long period, and a fixed-rate mortgage on a good building does exactly that. Commercial mortgages are one part of the insurer's investment portfolio, alongside bonds.
That purpose explains how life companies behave as lenders.
- They care more about safety than about earning the highest rate, so they prefer low-risk deals.
- They hold the loans they make, so you keep a lender (or its local servicing partner) to talk to after closing.
- They like long terms and dislike early repayment, because they have to reinvest the money.
- Each company sets a lending budget by property type and market. When a budget is filled, that company may stop quoting for a while.
For where life companies sit among other capital sources, see types of commercial real estate lenders.
Typical life company loan terms
| Term | Typical range |
|---|---|
| Loan term | 5 to 30 years; 10 years is common |
| Rate | Fixed, priced as a spread over Treasuries |
| Loan-to-value | Commonly about 50% to 65%, sometimes higher for the best deals |
| Amortization | Commonly 25 to 30 years; interest-only at low loan-to-value; fully amortizing loans available |
| Recourse | Usually non-recourse with standard carve-outs |
| Prepayment | Commonly yield maintenance, sometimes with negotiated flexibility |
| Loan size | Often $5 million and up; some run smaller-loan programs |
Coverage requirements are usually stricter than at other permanent lenders, and because the loan-to-value is moderate, the DSCR on a life company loan tends to be comfortably above the minimum. A hypothetical example: a property worth $20 million produces $1.2 million of NOI. At 60% loan-to-value the loan is $12 million, and the debt yield is 10% ($1.2 million divided by $12 million). A lender willing to go to 75% would offer $15 million, at an 8% debt yield. The life company gives you less money, at a lower rate, with less risk for both sides.
The deals life companies want
Life companies are selective about four things.
- Property type: apartments, industrial and warehouse, grocery-anchored and other well-leased retail, and well-leased office are the core. Self-storage and other types are financed by some companies.
- Quality: newer or well-maintained buildings that will still compete at the end of a long loan term.
- Location: larger metropolitan areas and strong secondary markets. Small or declining markets are harder.
- Income: stabilized, with a diverse rent roll or long leases to creditworthy tenants, and limited lease expirations during the loan term.
- Sponsor: experienced owners with real cash equity in the property and a clean record with past lenders.
They usually pass on properties in transition, heavy near-term lease rollover, special-purpose buildings and borrowers who need maximum proceeds. Those deals belong with bridge lenders, banks or conduit lenders.
Requesting less than the maximum helps. A life company that would decline a request at 65% loan-to-value may compete hard for the same property at 55%, because the lower loan fits its safest and most sought-after category. If you have the equity, ask what the pricing looks like at a lower loan amount before you decide how much to borrow.
Features that set life company loans apart
- Early rate lock: many life companies will lock the rate at application, usually with a deposit, instead of just before closing. That removes weeks of rate risk.
- Forward commitments: some will commit to a rate months before funding, which is useful when you are refinancing a loan that cannot be prepaid yet or buying a building that is still being finished.
- Long and fully amortizing terms: terms of 15, 20 or more years are available, including loans that pay down to zero.
- Lighter structure: at low loan-to-value there are often fewer reserves and no lockbox, and the documents can be negotiated more than on a securitized loan.
- A lender who holds the loan: consents for leases, easements or a partner change go to the lender or its servicer, which can decide on its own account.
The other side of a long fixed-rate loan is prepayment. Yield maintenance can be costly if rates fall and you want out, so match the term to your hold period. Prepayment penalties shows how the charge is calculated, and fixed vs. floating rate loans covers the wider trade-off.
Life company vs. CMBS vs. bank
| Life company | CMBS | Bank | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proceeds | Lower | Higher | Moderate |
| Rate type | Long-term fixed | Fixed, 5 or 10 years | Floating or short fixed periods |
| Recourse | Usually non-recourse | Non-recourse | Often recourse |
| After closing | Lender holds the loan | Servicer under pool rules | Lender holds the loan |
| Prepayment | Yield maintenance | Defeasance or yield maintenance | Often a step-down schedule |
| Best fit | Strong property, long hold | Stabilized property needing more proceeds | Smaller or transitional deals, relationships |
If the choice is between a life company and a conduit, the usual question is whether the extra proceeds are worth the heavier structure. CMBS loans explained describes what that structure involves.
How to approach a life company
Most life companies do not take loan requests from the public. They work through correspondents: mortgage banking firms that originate loans for them in a region and often service those loans afterward. A few lend directly on large loans. A correspondent or a mortgage broker with life company relationships is the normal route, which is one case where the answer in broker vs. going direct leans toward an intermediary.
- Check the fit first: property type, market, loan size and a loan-to-value in their range.
- Prepare a clean package with the rent roll, operating history, lease summaries and sponsor background. See what lenders want in a loan request package.
- Ask for quotes at two or three loan-to-value levels, because the spread often improves as the loan gets smaller.
- Ask about rate lock timing, prepayment options and any reserves before you sign the application.
A fast no is normal and not a judgment on your deal. It usually means the property is outside that company's current targets. Terms vary by company and change over time, so confirm them with the lender and your own counsel.
Where CREaiD helps
Deciding whether a deal is life company quality, and what the alternatives would be, starts with knowing how lenders view your property type and market.
CREaiD's Insights tool gives current debt financing market insights by location and asset type. Its Lender Matchmaker then lets you describe the deal and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders. It has a free version.
Key takeaways
- Life companies make long-term, fixed-rate loans with their own money and usually hold them.
- They offer low rates in exchange for moderate loan-to-value on strong, stabilized properties.
- Early rate locks, forward commitments and fully amortizing terms are common advantages.
- Most borrowers reach life companies through correspondents or mortgage brokers.
Questions people ask
What is the minimum loan size for a life company?
It varies. Many life companies prefer loans of $5 million or more, and the largest focus on much bigger loans. Some run smaller-loan programs through their correspondents, so a smaller deal is not automatically excluded.
Do life companies make construction loans?
Mostly they make permanent loans on finished, leased properties. Some offer construction-to-permanent loans or forward commitments that fund when a building is completed. For standard construction financing, banks are the main source.
Why is the loan-to-value lower than other lenders offer?
The insurer is investing policyholder money for the long term and wants a large equity cushion under its loan. The lower risk is also why the rate is lower. If you need more proceeds, a conduit loan or a bank may fit better.
Can I add mezzanine debt behind a life company loan?
Often not. Many life companies prohibit or tightly limit subordinate financing, because they want the sponsor's own equity in the deal. Ask before you apply if you plan to bring in gap capital.
How is the rate on a life company loan set?
It is a spread over the Treasury yield for a similar term. The spread depends on loan-to-value, property type, market and the quality of the income. Many life companies will lock the rate at application, which fixes it early in the process.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
