
How each rate is priced
Every commercial loan rate has two parts: an index and a spread. The index is a market rate the lender does not control. The spread is the lender's margin for the risk of your deal, and it reflects property type, loan-to-value, coverage and the sponsor.
- Fixed rate: the index is usually the Treasury yield or swap rate for a term that matches the loan. It is read once, at rate lock, added to the spread, and the result does not change for the fixed period.
- Floating rate: the index is a short-term rate, commonly SOFR, or the prime rate at some banks. It resets on a schedule, usually monthly. The spread stays the same, so your rate moves one for one with the index.
- Floor: many floating-rate loans set a minimum for the index or the total rate. If the index falls below the floor, your rate stops falling.
- Hybrid: many bank loans are fixed for an initial period, such as five years, and then reset or float.
Because the index for a fixed-rate loan can move until the lock, ask every lender when the rate is locked and what it costs to lock early.
Fixed vs. floating side by side
| Fixed rate | Floating rate | |
|---|---|---|
| Payment | Stays the same | Changes when the index resets |
| Typical lenders | CMBS, agencies, HUD, life companies, banks | Bridge lenders, debt funds, construction lenders, banks |
| Typical use | Stabilized property, long hold | Value-add, lease-up, construction |
| Prepayment | Yield maintenance, defeasance or a step-down | Often open after a minimum interest period |
| Main risk | Being locked in when you want out | Payments rising faster than income |
| Hedging | Not needed | Rate cap or swap often required |
The loan type usually comes with a rate type. Permanent programs such as CMBS and life company loans are fixed, while most bridge loans float. Banks and the agencies offer both.
What floating-rate risk looks like in numbers
On an interest-only loan, each one-point move in the index changes annual interest by 1% of the balance. A hypothetical example: you have a $10 million floating-rate, interest-only loan and the property earns $900,000 of NOI. At the starting rate, interest costs $700,000 a year, so the DSCR is about 1.29x.
- If the index rises one point, interest rises by $100,000 to $800,000 and DSCR falls to about 1.13x.
- If it rises two points, interest is $900,000 and DSCR is 1.00x. Every dollar of NOI goes to the lender.
- If it rises three points, interest is $1,000,000 and you are paying $100,000 a year out of pocket.
The higher payments are only half of the problem. Floating-rate loans often have extension tests based on DSCR or debt yield, and a higher rate also shrinks the permanent loan the property can support when you refinance. Run the same stress on your exit as on your monthly payment.
Tools that limit floating-rate risk
- Interest rate cap: you pay a one-time price for a contract that pays you whenever the index is above a set level, called the strike. Your effective index is then limited to the strike for the life of the cap. Many bridge lenders require one. The cap has its own end date, and a new one usually must be bought to extend the loan.
- Interest rate swap: common with bank loans. You exchange your floating payments for fixed ones, so the loan behaves like a fixed-rate loan. If you repay early, the swap is settled at market value, and you may owe or receive a breakage amount depending on where rates are.
- Interest reserve: cash set aside at closing to cover payments during a renovation or lease-up.
- Lower loan amount: the simplest protection. A smaller loan leaves more room for the rate to rise before coverage gets thin.
A cap costs more when the strike is low, the term is long or the market expects rates to rise. Get a price for the cap at the same time as the loan quote, because it is a real closing cost.
The cost of a fixed rate: prepayment
A fixed rate is a promise in both directions. You are protected if rates rise, and the lender or its investors are protected if rates fall. That protection is the prepayment penalty.
- Yield maintenance: you pay the lender roughly the interest it will lose by reinvesting at lower market rates.
- Defeasance: you replace the property as collateral with government securities that make the remaining payments.
- Step-down: a percentage of the balance that declines each year, such as 5%, 4%, 3%, 2%, 1%. This is common with banks and easier to plan around.
Yield maintenance and defeasance can be very expensive when rates have dropped since closing and modest when rates have risen. Prepayment penalties works through each method. If you might sell during the term, look for a loan a buyer can assume, a step-down schedule or a shorter fixed period. Also check how the fixed period lines up with any interest-only period, covered in interest-only periods and amortization.
How to choose
Start with the business plan, not with a forecast of rates. Nobody predicts rates reliably, and a loan that only works if rates move your way is a bet.
- How long will you hold? Match the fixed period to the hold. If you expect to exit in two or three years, a ten-year fixed loan with yield maintenance is usually the wrong choice.
- Is the income stabilized? Fixed-rate permanent lenders need in-place income. If the property is in transition, floating-rate debt is usually what is available.
- Can the property absorb a higher rate? Run the stress test above. If a two-point rise breaks the deal, borrow less, buy a cap or fix the rate.
- What is flexibility worth to you? Put a number on the prepayment cost in the fixed quote and compare it with the cap cost and rate risk in the floating quote.
- What does each lender require? Compare complete offers, including hedging, reserves and extension terms. How to compare term sheets gives a method.
A common path is to use both in sequence: floating-rate debt while you carry out the plan, then a fixed-rate permanent loan once the income is in place. Rate terms differ by lender and by day, so confirm them with the lender and your own counsel before you lock.
Where CREaiD helps
The right structure depends on what lenders are offering for your property type and market at the time you borrow.
CREaiD's Insights tool gives current debt financing market insights by location and asset type. You can also upload deal data for a quick investment analysis, and use the Lender Matchmaker to get lenders that fit the deal you describe.
Key takeaways
- Every rate is an index plus a spread; a fixed rate reads the index once, and a floating rate resets it on a schedule.
- Fixed rates give certainty but carry prepayment penalties; floating rates give flexibility but carry payment risk.
- On an interest-only loan, each one-point rise adds 1% of the balance to annual interest.
- Caps and swaps limit floating-rate risk, and both have a cost.
- Choose by hold period and business plan, not by a guess about where rates are going.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper, a fixed or a floating rate?
It depends on the market on the day you borrow and on what happens afterward. Sometimes the starting floating rate is lower and sometimes the fixed rate is. Compare total expected cost over your hold, including the cap, fees and the likely prepayment charge.
What is SOFR?
SOFR is the Secured Overnight Financing Rate, a benchmark based on overnight borrowing backed by Treasury securities. It replaced LIBOR as the main index for floating-rate commercial loans in the United States. Loan documents specify which version of SOFR applies and how often it resets.
What is an interest rate cap?
It is a contract you buy from a financial institution that pays you when the index rises above the strike rate. It limits how high your effective rate can go without removing the benefit if rates fall. Lenders that require one usually set the strike, the term and the minimum credit rating of the provider.
Can I convert a floating-rate loan to a fixed rate?
Sometimes. With a bank loan you may be able to add a swap that fixes your payments. Otherwise the usual route is to refinance into a fixed-rate permanent loan once the property qualifies.
When is the rate locked on a fixed-rate loan?
It varies by lender. Conduit loans typically lock shortly before closing, agency loans after the loan is approved, and many life companies will lock at application with a deposit. Until the lock, the index can move, so ask about timing when you compare quotes.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
