Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

For mortgage brokers · 7 min read

How to Compare Commercial Loan Term Sheets

Short answer

Compare commercial loan term sheets by putting every offer on one grid and judging four things in order: net loan proceeds, the total cost of the money over the time you expect to hold the loan, the terms that restrict you or cost you later (prepayment, recourse, reserves, covenants), and how likely the lender is to close on the terms quoted. The lowest rate is often not the best loan.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What a term sheet is, and what it is not

A term sheet (also called a letter of intent or a quote) is the lender's outline of the loan it expects to make. It is usually non-binding on the loan terms. The lender has not finished underwriting, received the appraisal or gone to credit committee, so anything in it can change.

Some parts are often binding once you sign: the expense deposit, confidentiality, and sometimes an exclusivity clause that stops you from working with other lenders for a period. Read those first. The binding promise to lend comes later, in a commitment letter or in the loan documents.

Lenders also write term sheets differently. One quotes a rate, another quotes a spread over an index. One lists every fee, another refers to customary costs. Your first job is to make the offers comparable. If you are still deciding how many lenders to approach, aim for enough quotes to see a pattern.

Put every offer on one grid

Build a simple table with one column per lender and the same rows for each. Where a term sheet is silent, write 'not stated' and ask. The gaps are usually where the surprises are.

LineWhat to recordWhy it matters
Loan amountDollar amount and the LTV, DSCR or debt yield limit behind itThe amount can be cut after the appraisal
RateFixed or floating, index, spread, floor, when it locksSets your payment and your rate risk
Term and amortizationLoan term, amortization, interest-only period, extensionsDrives cash flow and refinance timing
FeesOrigination, exit, extension, lender legal, depositsChanges the true cost
PrepaymentLockout, yield maintenance, defeasance or step-downCost of selling or refinancing early
RecourseFull, partial or non-recourse, carve-outs, guarantor testsYour personal exposure
Reserves and controlsTax, insurance, replacement and leasing reserves, cash managementCash you cannot touch

Once the grid is filled in, the offers usually sort themselves into two or three real contenders.

Compare proceeds and cost with real numbers

Start with what you actually receive. Net proceeds are the loan amount minus origination fees, reserves funded at closing and lender costs. A larger loan with heavy upfront reserves can put less cash in your hands than a smaller, cleaner one.

Then compare cost over the time you expect to hold the loan, not over the full term. Say Lender A and Lender B both offer $5,000,000. A's rate is 0.25% lower, but A charges a 1% origination fee and B charges 0.5%. The rate difference is worth about $12,500 a year ($5,000,000 x 0.25%). The fee difference is $25,000 ($50,000 versus $25,000). A needs two years to earn back its higher fee. If you plan to hold for seven years, A is cheaper. If you plan to sell in 18 months, B is.

Do the same with amortization. An interest-only period lowers the payment and raises cash flow, but you pay down no principal, so the balance at maturity is higher. The mechanics are in interest-only periods and amortization. For a floating-rate quote, compare the spread, the floor and any required rate cap, and read fixed vs. floating rate loans before treating a lower starting rate as a saving.

The terms that cost you later

These lines get less attention than the rate and cause more regret.

  • Prepayment: a step-down penalty is a known percentage. Yield maintenance and defeasance depend on where rates are when you exit and can be very large. Match the structure to your plan with the guide to prepayment penalties.
  • Recourse: a non-recourse loan still has carve-outs for acts such as fraud or unauthorized transfers, and some carve-outs make the whole loan recourse. Compare the lists and see recourse vs. non-recourse loans.
  • Guarantor covenants: minimum net worth and liquidity you must maintain for the life of the loan.
  • Cash management: a lockbox or cash sweep that starts if DSCR or occupancy falls below a stated level.
  • Ongoing reserves: monthly deposits for replacements, tenant improvements and leasing commissions reduce the cash you can distribute.
  • Extension options: the fee, and the tests you must pass to use them. An extension you cannot qualify for is not an option.
  • Transfer and assumption: whether a buyer can assume the loan, and at what cost.

Judge certainty of execution

A term sheet is only as good as the lender's ability and intent to close on it. Some lenders quote aggressively to win the deal and then cut proceeds or widen the spread after the appraisal, when you are out of time. This is called a retrade, and it is the main reason experienced borrowers do not simply take the highest quote.

  • Has the lender closed this property type, in this market, at this loan size?
  • Who approves the loan, and has the deal been discussed with that person or committee yet?
  • What assumptions is the quote built on (appraised value, underwritten NOI, occupancy), and are they realistic?
  • How long is it from a signed term sheet to closing, and does that fit your contract deadline?
  • What deposit is required, and what part comes back if the lender changes the terms?

On a purchase with a hard closing date, a slightly more expensive loan from a lender who will close on time is often the better choice.

Negotiate, then choose

You have the most bargaining power before you sign and pay a deposit. Use the grid. Go back to your top two lenders with specific requests: a lower floor, a shorter lockout, recourse that burns off when the property reaches a stated DSCR, a smaller reserve. Ask for the one or two things that matter to your plan, not ten.

Be straight about competing offers. Lenders talk to each other, and a made-up quote damages your credibility on the next deal. When you choose, tell the other lenders quickly and politely. You will want them next time. Budget for the costs that sit outside the term sheet too, covered in closing costs and fees.

A term sheet is a summary. Confirm every term with the lender and have your own counsel review the commitment and loan documents before you sign.

Where CREaiD helps

You can only compare term sheets if you have more than one. CREaiD's Lender Matchmaker takes a description of your deal and returns lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders.

That helps you put the request in front of enough of the right lenders to get competing quotes. Try the Lender Matchmaker.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • A term sheet is usually non-binding on loan terms, but deposits and exclusivity can bind you.
  • Put every offer on one grid with the same rows before judging any of them.
  • Compare cost over your expected hold period, not only the rate.
  • Prepayment, recourse carve-outs, reserves and cash management often matter more than a small rate difference.
  • Weigh how likely each lender is to close on the terms it quoted.

Questions people ask

Is a commercial loan term sheet binding?

Usually not on the loan terms themselves. Provisions on expense deposits, confidentiality and exclusivity are often binding once you sign. The lender's binding obligation normally starts with a commitment letter or the signed loan documents.

What is a retrade?

A retrade is when a lender changes the terms after you signed the term sheet, usually by lowering proceeds or raising the rate after the appraisal or underwriting. Some changes are justified by new facts. You reduce the risk by choosing lenders with a record of closing on quoted terms and by testing the assumptions behind the quote.

Should I take the offer with the highest loan amount?

Not automatically. Check net proceeds after fees and reserves, the rate and the terms attached, and ask what the amount depends on. A high quote that relies on an optimistic appraisal can shrink before closing.

How many term sheets do I need to compare?

At least two or three comparable quotes give you a sense of the market for your deal and something to negotiate with. More is not always better, because each serious quote takes lender time and your attention. Quality of fit matters more than the count.

Can I negotiate a term sheet?

Yes, and the best time is before you sign it and pay the deposit. Focus on the terms that affect your business plan, such as prepayment flexibility, recourse, reserves and extension tests. Lenders are more flexible on structure than most borrowers expect.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free