Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Finding a lender · 7 min read

How Many Lenders Should You Approach for a Commercial Loan?

Short answer

For a straightforward deal, approach three to five lenders that clearly make that kind of loan. For a harder deal (transitional property, construction, unusual asset or a thin borrower profile), plan on ten to twenty, usually in two rounds. One lender gives you no comparison, and a mass mailing to fifty wastes time and can hurt the deal.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why one lender is not enough

A single quote tells you what one credit committee thinks. It does not tell you what the market will offer. Commercial loans are not standardized the way home mortgages are. Two lenders looking at the same property can differ on loan amount, rate, recourse, amortization, fees and prepayment terms, sometimes by a wide margin.

There is also deal risk. A lender can lose interest halfway through: a credit officer objects, the appraisal comes in low, or the bank reaches its limit for that property type. If you have no second option and a purchase contract deadline is close, you have very little room to negotiate. A backup lender that already knows the deal protects your closing date.

Going to one lender can still be right in a few cases: a small loan with your long-time bank, a repeat deal with a lender that financed your last three, or a program loan where pricing is set by formula. Even then, one outside quote is a cheap way to check the offer.

Why fifty is too many

Sending a deal to every lender you can find feels thorough. In practice it creates four problems.

  • You cannot manage it. Every interested lender has questions and document requests. Past a dozen active conversations, answers get slow and sloppy, and slow answers cost you credibility.
  • Most recipients do not make that loan. A blast ignores each lender's credit box, so most of the effort produces a no or silence.
  • The deal looks shopped. Loan officers talk, and many lenders are funded by the same capital sources. A request that has landed on every desk, sometimes from several people at once, reads as a deal nobody wanted.
  • Your information travels. Rent rolls, financial statements and purchase terms are confidential. The more inboxes they reach, the less control you have.

The same applies if you use brokers. Hiring several brokers to cover the market usually means the same lender gets the same deal twice, with different numbers. Lenders tend to step back from that. The broker question is covered in commercial mortgage broker vs. going direct to a lender.

The right number depends on the deal

The harder the deal is to place, the wider the search needs to be. Use this as a starting point and adjust for your market.

DealLenders to approachWhy
Stabilized property, common type, strong borrower3 to 5Many lenders want it, so a few good quotes show the market
Small-balance loan in a local market3 to 5 local lendersCommunity banks and credit unions price similar loans every week
Value-add or bridge loan6 to 10Bridge lenders differ widely on proceeds, fees and structure
Ground-up construction5 to 10Fewer lenders are active, and each is selective about sponsors
Unusual asset or challenged borrower10 to 20, in roundsThe lender that fits may be one of very few

These are counts of well-matched lenders. Ten lenders that fund your property type, market and loan size are worth more than forty names pulled from a list. The matching step is described in how to find a commercial real estate lender.

Run the search in stages

A staged process gives you competition without chaos. It also lets you improve the request between rounds, using what the first lenders told you.

  1. Build a long list. Collect fifteen to thirty names from the lender types that fit the deal.
  2. Screen by phone or email. Ask about property type, location, loan size and recourse. Cut anyone who fails a hard limit.
  3. Send round one. Give the same complete package to your best five to eight lenders on the same day.
  4. Listen to the feedback. If three lenders raise the same concern, fix the package or the request before anyone else sees it.
  5. Send round two if needed. Go to the next group only if round one did not produce at least two usable quotes.
  6. Narrow to two or three finalists. Ask each for a written term sheet.

A consistent package matters more than the count. What lenders want to see in a commercial loan request package lists what to include, and how to get a commercial loan officer to answer you covers the outreach itself.

When to stop and choose

Stop searching when you have two or three written term sheets from lenders you believe can close. More quotes after that point rarely change the outcome, and they delay the application.

Compare the offers on total cost and certainty, not only on rate. Consider a hypothetical $4,000,000 loan. Lender A quotes a slightly lower rate with a 1% origination fee ($40,000) and a stiff prepayment penalty. Lender B quotes a slightly higher rate with a 0.5% fee ($20,000) and flexible prepayment. If you plan to sell in three years, Lender B may cost less overall. The method is in how to compare commercial loan term sheets.

Sign one term sheet and pay one application deposit. Deposits cover the appraisal and other third-party reports, and they are usually not refundable once the reports are ordered. Tell the runner-up politely that you are going another way and ask whether you may come back if something changes. Most loan officers appreciate the honesty and will keep the file open. That matters more than it seems. If the chosen lender cuts the loan amount after the appraisal or changes a key term late in the process, a runner-up who already knows the property can often step in within days, while a new lender would have to start from the beginning.

Where CREaiD helps you get to the right number

The hard part of this process is building a list of lenders that actually fit, so that five calls are enough. CREaiD's Lender Matchmaker lets you describe a deal and get lenders that fit it from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders. That gives you a targeted long list to screen, instead of a mass mailing. There is a free version.

Every lender's terms and deposit rules are different, so confirm them in writing with the lender and review the term sheet with your own counsel before you sign.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Three to five well-matched lenders are enough for a simple deal, and ten to twenty in rounds suits a hard one.
  • One quote shows you a single opinion and leaves you without a backup if the lender drops out.
  • Mass outreach makes a deal look shopped and spreads confidential information widely.
  • Work in stages: screen, send a first round, fix what lenders flag, then widen only if needed.
  • Stop at two or three credible term sheets, then sign one and pay one deposit.

Questions people ask

Does contacting several commercial lenders hurt my credit?

Preliminary quotes are usually based on the property and a summary of your finances, without a credit pull. A lender typically checks credit after you sign a term sheet or submit a formal application. Ask each lender when it pulls credit so there are no surprises.

Should I tell lenders I am talking to other lenders?

Yes, in general terms. Saying that you are speaking with a few lenders and plan to choose by a certain date is normal and tends to speed up responses. You do not need to name the others or share their quotes.

Can I sign more than one term sheet?

It is a bad idea. Most term sheets require a deposit and many include an exclusivity clause for a set period. Signing two can cost you both deposits and damage your standing with both lenders.

How many lenders does a commercial mortgage broker contact?

It varies with the deal. A broker with a strong network may go to a handful of lenders for a simple loan and a few dozen for a difficult one. Ask the broker which lenders will see your deal, so that nobody is contacted twice.

What if only one lender gives me a quote?

Treat that as information about the request, not only about the lenders. Ask the ones who passed for their reason, adjust the loan amount or structure if the reasons agree, and run a second round with a different lender type.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free