Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Finding a lender · 7 min read

Commercial Mortgage Broker vs. Going Direct to a Lender

Short answer

Go direct when the deal is simple, you already know lenders that make that loan, and you have time to run the process. Use a commercial mortgage broker when the deal is complex, large, unusual or urgent, or when you do not know the lender market. A broker adds a fee, and a good one earns it through better terms, more options and a smoother closing.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What each route involves

Going direct means you find lenders, send the request, answer questions, compare quotes and negotiate the term sheet yourself. You deal with the lender's loan officer, who works for the lender.

Using a broker means you hire an intermediary to do that work. A commercial mortgage broker does not lend money. The broker packages the deal, takes it to lenders in its network, collects quotes, helps you choose and stays involved through closing. The broker works for you, although it is usually paid at closing from loan proceeds, and in some cases by the lender.

One point confuses many borrowers. Some firms are both. A mortgage banking firm may lend directly under agency programs, act as correspondent for life insurance companies and broker everything else. Ask any firm you speak with which role it would play on your loan.

Broker vs. direct at a glance

FactorGoing directUsing a broker
CostNo broker feeFee, often around 1% of the loan
Lender optionsThe lenders you know or can findThe broker's network across lender types
Your timeYou run the whole processThe broker packages, markets and follows up
Market knowledgeLimited to your own recent dealsSees current quotes across many deals
NegotiationYou negotiate aloneBroker knows which terms each lender will bend on
ControlDirect relationship with the lenderCommunication runs through the broker at first

Neither column wins every time. The right choice depends on the deal in front of you and on how well you already know the lenders for it.

What a broker costs, and whether it pays

Broker fees are negotiable and set out in a written engagement agreement. A fee of about 1% of the loan amount is common on mid-size loans. The percentage tends to be higher on small loans and lower on very large ones. Some lenders also pay the broker a fee, which should be disclosed to you. How fees work in detail is covered in how commercial mortgage brokers get paid.

Work out whether the fee is likely to pay for itself. Take a hypothetical $4,000,000 loan with a 1% broker fee of $40,000. If the broker finds a loan with a rate 0.25 percentage points lower than you would have found alone, the interest saving is roughly $10,000 a year ($4,000,000 times 0.0025), or about $50,000 over five years on an interest-only basis. That covers the fee. If the broker also gets a larger loan, a longer interest-only period or non-recourse terms, the value is higher, though harder to put a number on.

The reverse is also true. If you would have gone to the same lender and received the same terms, the fee bought you convenience only. That can still be worth it if your time is better spent elsewhere, but you should know which case you are in.

When going direct makes sense

  • You have a relationship. Your bank knows you, holds your deposits and financed your last deal on fair terms.
  • The deal is simple. A stabilized property of a common type, at a moderate loan amount, in a market with many lenders.
  • The loan is small. On a small-balance loan, local banks and credit unions are easy to reach and a broker fee takes a bigger share. See how to find a lender for a small-balance commercial loan.
  • It is a program loan. Agency, HUD and SBA loans come through approved lenders you can contact yourself.
  • You have the time and the package. You can prepare a complete request and manage several conversations at once.

If you go direct, still get more than one quote. Three to five well-matched lenders are usually enough, as explained in how many lenders should you approach for a commercial loan. The search steps are in how to find a commercial real estate lender.

When a broker earns the fee

  • The deal is hard to place. Transitional properties, construction, special-use buildings or a borrower with a weak spot need lenders that are not easy to find.
  • The capital stack has layers. Combining a senior loan with mezzanine debt or preferred equity takes coordination among several parties.
  • The loan is large. Small differences in terms are worth real money, and more lender types compete.
  • You are new to the market or the property type. A broker who closes these loans every month knows who is lending now and on what terms.
  • Time is short. A broker can run a wide search in parallel while you handle due diligence on the purchase.
  • Your bank said no. A decline from one lender says little about the rest of the market.

Bridge lending is a common case. The lender field is fragmented and quotes vary widely, which is covered in how to find a bridge lender for commercial property.

How to choose a broker

Brokers differ as much as lenders do. Ask these questions before you sign an engagement letter.

  1. How many loans like mine have you closed, and with which types of lenders?
  2. Which lenders do you plan to show this deal to, and will you tell me before you send it?
  3. What is your fee, when is it earned, and will any lender also pay you?
  4. Is the engagement exclusive, for how long, and how can I end it?
  5. Do I owe a fee if I close with a lender I found myself, or after the agreement ends?
  6. Who at your firm will actually work on my deal?
  7. Are you licensed where the property is located, if the state requires it?

Licensing rules for commercial mortgage brokers vary by state, so check the rule for your state. Ask for two or three borrower references from recent deals, and read the tail clause, the part of the agreement that says when a fee is owed after the engagement ends. Hire one broker per deal. Two brokers sending the same request to the same lenders hurts your credibility with both.

Where CREaiD fits for investors and brokers

CREaiD is an AI assistant for commercial real estate financing, built for both investors and mortgage brokers. Its Lender Matchmaker lets you describe a deal and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders. An investor going direct can use it to build a list, and a broker can use it to widen a network. It does not replace a broker's judgment or a lender's underwriting. It has a free version.

Fees, exclusivity and loan terms are all set by contract, so confirm them with the broker and the lender and have your own counsel review the agreements.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Go direct on simple, small or program loans when you already know lenders that fit.
  • Use a broker when the deal is complex, large, urgent or outside the market you know.
  • A broker fee is often around 1% of the loan, and it should be weighed against better terms and saved time.
  • Some firms lend directly on some loans and broker others, so ask which role they would play.
  • Read the engagement agreement closely, especially exclusivity and when a fee is owed.

Questions people ask

Who pays the commercial mortgage broker?

Usually the borrower, at closing, from loan proceeds. On some loans the lender pays part or all of the fee. Either way, the cost is part of the deal, so ask the broker to disclose every source of compensation in writing.

Do lenders give better terms to brokers than to borrowers who come direct?

Not as a rule. A lender's pricing is driven by the deal. A broker can improve the outcome by creating competition, presenting the deal well and knowing which lender is most eager for that loan type at the moment.

Can I talk to lenders myself while a broker is working on my deal?

Check the engagement agreement first. Many are exclusive, and you may owe the fee even on a loan you find yourself. If you want to keep your own bank in the running, name it as an exclusion before you sign.

Is a commercial mortgage broker the same as a mortgage banker?

No. A broker arranges loans made by others. A mortgage banker originates loans in its own name, often under agency programs or as a correspondent for other lenders, and may service them afterward. Many firms do both, depending on the loan.

Does a broker make sense for a refinance with my current lender?

Often not for the refinance itself, since you already have the relationship. A broker can still be useful to test the market so you know whether your current lender's offer is competitive. Agree on the fee terms for that case in advance.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free