Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

For mortgage brokers · 8 min read

How Commercial Mortgage Brokers Get Paid

Short answer

Commercial mortgage brokers are usually paid a success fee at closing, calculated as a percentage of the loan amount. It is commonly around 1%, and often between about 0.5% and 2% depending on loan size and difficulty. The borrower, the lender or both can pay it, and it normally comes out of loan proceeds on the closing statement. If the loan does not close, the broker usually earns nothing unless the agreement says otherwise.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The success fee: a percentage of the loan

Most commercial mortgage brokers work on contingency. You do the work up front (packaging the deal, choosing lenders, negotiating terms, pushing the closing) and you are paid one fee when the loan funds. The fee is quoted in points, where one point equals 1% of the loan amount.

Say you arrange a $4,000,000 loan at a one point fee. The fee is $40,000. It appears as a line on the closing statement and the title or escrow company pays it from loan proceeds. On a $20,000,000 loan the percentage is commonly lower, because the dollar amount is already large. On a $600,000 loan it is commonly higher, often with a minimum dollar fee, because a small loan can take as much work as a big one.

Several things move the percentage up or down:

  • Loan size: larger loans typically carry a lower percentage.
  • Difficulty: construction, bridge and turnaround deals take more work than a stabilized refinance and are usually priced higher.
  • Capital stack work: placing subordinate capital next to the senior loan is often billed as a separate fee on that piece.
  • Relationship: repeat clients with steady deal flow often negotiate a lower fee.

Who pays: borrower, lender or both

The fee can come from more than one place. Which arrangement applies depends on the lender type and on what your agreement says.

Who paysHow it worksWhere you see it
BorrowerBorrower signs a fee agreement and pays a percentage at closingLine on the closing statement
LenderLender shares part of its origination fee or pays a fee built into the loan pricingTerm sheet or a lender and broker agreement
BothBorrower pays a reduced fee and the lender pays the restBoth documents
CorrespondentIntermediary with a standing lender relationship earns an origination fee and sometimes an ongoing servicing feeCorrespondent agreement

Borrower-paid fees are the most common arrangement with banks and credit unions, which usually do not pay outside brokers themselves. Many private, bridge and hard money lenders will pay or protect a broker fee, often by adding it to their own points. Correspondent relationships are common with life insurance companies, where the intermediary may also service the loan after closing.

Whoever writes the check, the borrower bears the cost in the end, either as a fee or as a slightly higher rate. That is why disclosure matters. A borrower should know every dollar you earn on the deal. Government-backed programs add their own rules: SBA loans have specific rules on what agents can charge and require those fees to be disclosed.

Other fees you may see

The success fee is the main source of income, but it is not the only way brokers bill.

  • Retainer or engagement fee: a modest upfront payment to cover packaging work, often credited against the success fee at closing. It is more common on hard deals and with established firms.
  • Processing fee: a flat fee for assembling the package and the financial model.
  • Subordinate capital fee: a separate percentage for raising mezzanine debt or preferred equity, typically higher than the fee on senior debt because that capital is harder to place.
  • Consulting fee: hourly or flat pay for advisory work that may not end in a new loan, such as a loan modification.

Borrowers should be careful with anyone who asks for a large upfront fee before showing real lender interest. Legitimate third-party costs (appraisal, environmental report, lender legal) are paid to the lender or the vendor, not to the broker, and they belong in the borrower's budget for closing costs and fees. Some states also regulate advance fees for loan brokerage.

What the fee agreement should say

A handshake is how brokers lose fees. Get a signed agreement before you send the deal to a single lender. If you are the borrower, read the same terms from the other side.

  • The fee and its base: the percentage and what it applies to (the total loan amount including future funding, or only the initial advance).
  • When it is earned: at closing and funding is standard. Some agreements say the fee is also owed if the borrower walks away from an approved loan.
  • Exclusive or non-exclusive: an exclusive gives the broker the sole right to place the loan for a set period. A non-exclusive agreement usually protects only the lenders the broker introduces.
  • Tail period: if the borrower closes with a lender you introduced within a stated time after the agreement ends, you are still paid.
  • Registered lenders: a written list of who you approached, so there is no argument later.
  • Other compensation: any lender-paid amount, disclosed in writing.

Exclusivity is the term both sides argue about most. Brokers want it because lenders dislike seeing the same deal arrive from three directions, and because it protects weeks of unpaid work. Borrowers resist it when they have their own bank relationships. A common compromise is an exclusive with a carve-out for lenders the borrower names up front. The wider tradeoff is covered in broker vs. going direct to a lender.

How the fee is split inside a brokerage

The fee on the closing statement is not what the individual broker takes home. If you work under a firm, the firm takes its share first. The split depends on who sourced the client and how much support the firm provides.

Take the same $40,000 fee. On a hypothetical 60/40 split in the broker's favor, the broker keeps $24,000 and the firm keeps $16,000. If another broker referred the client in exchange for a quarter of your share, that is $6,000 out of your $24,000, leaving $18,000. New brokers usually start on a lower split and move up as production grows. Independent brokers keep the whole fee and pay all of their own costs.

Co-brokering is common too. One broker has the borrower, another has the lender relationship, and they agree to share the fee. Put that in writing. Check your state's rules before paying or receiving a referral fee: some states require a license to broker commercial mortgages or to collect a fee for it, and the rules differ by state. Licensing is covered in how to become a commercial mortgage broker.

Because income arrives only at closing, your pipeline matters more than any single fee. A broker with a wide lender network closes more of what comes in, because fewer deals die for lack of a fit. This is general information: confirm fee terms with the lender and your own counsel before you sign.

Where CREaiD fits

CREaiD does not change how you are paid. It helps with the unpaid part of the job that comes before the fee.

Describe a deal to the Lender Matchmaker and it returns lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders. The Sales & Marketing tool drafts outreach emails and property summaries. See how brokers use it on the mortgage brokers page.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Most commercial mortgage brokers earn a success fee at closing, quoted in points on the loan amount.
  • The percentage is commonly around 1% and moves with loan size and difficulty.
  • The borrower, the lender or both can pay, and all compensation should be disclosed in writing.
  • A signed fee agreement with clear exclusivity, tail and registered lender terms protects both sides.
  • Individual brokers at a firm keep only their split of the fee.

Questions people ask

What is a typical commercial mortgage broker fee?

It is commonly about 1% of the loan amount, with a usual range of roughly 0.5% to 2%. Small loans sit at the high end or carry a minimum dollar fee, and very large loans sit at the low end. Deals that are hard to place cost more than a simple refinance.

Does a broker get paid if the loan does not close?

Usually not. The standard arrangement is a success fee that is earned only when the loan closes and funds. Some agreements include a retainer, or a fee that is owed if the borrower refuses a loan that matches the terms requested, so read the agreement.

Can a broker be paid by both the borrower and the lender?

In many cases yes, as long as both payments are disclosed. Some loan programs restrict or prohibit it, and some lenders will not pay outside brokers at all. Ask for all compensation to be listed in writing.

Is the broker fee negotiable?

Yes. The fee is set by agreement between the borrower and the broker, and loan size, expected workload and repeat business all affect it. Negotiate before the broker starts approaching lenders, not at the closing table.

Do commercial mortgage brokers need a license to collect a fee?

It depends on the state. Some states require a specific license or a real estate broker license to arrange commercial mortgages for a fee, and others do not. Check the rules in each state where the property or the borrower is located.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free