Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Loan types · 7 min read

Mezzanine Debt vs. Preferred Equity

Short answer

Both fill the gap between the senior loan and the sponsor's equity, and both cost more than the first mortgage. Mezzanine debt is a loan secured by a pledge of the ownership interests in the entity that owns the property. Preferred equity is an investment in that entity with a priority right to distributions. The main differences are the remedies if things go wrong, how the senior lender treats each one and how each is taxed.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Where gap capital sits in the capital stack

The capital stack is the list of everyone who funds a deal, in order of who gets paid first. The senior mortgage is at the top of the payment order and carries the least risk. The sponsor's common equity is at the bottom: paid last, first to absorb losses and entitled to whatever is left. Mezzanine debt and preferred equity sit in between.

A hypothetical example. A project costs $20 million. A senior lender provides 60% of cost, or $12 million. Without gap capital the sponsor needs $8 million of equity. If a mezzanine lender or preferred equity investor adds $3 million, taking the financing from 60% to 75% of cost, the sponsor needs $5 million.

The sponsor gives up some cash flow and takes on more risk in exchange for writing a smaller check. Whether that is a good trade depends on the price of the gap capital and on how much room the property's income leaves.

How mezzanine debt works

A mezzanine loan is not a second mortgage. It is made to the entity that owns the property-owning entity, one level up. The collateral is a pledge of the ownership interests, not a lien on the real estate.

  • Payments: interest, fixed or floating, usually paid monthly. Some loans let part of the interest accrue and be paid at maturity.
  • Term: usually matches the senior loan, so both come due together.
  • Remedy: if the mezzanine loan defaults, the lender can foreclose on the pledged interests under the Uniform Commercial Code. This is generally faster than a mortgage foreclosure. The mezzanine lender then owns the property-owning entity, with the senior loan still in place.
  • Intercreditor agreement: the senior and mezzanine lenders sign an agreement that sets out the mezzanine lender's rights to receive notices, cure senior loan defaults and take over the borrower.
  • Guaranties: the sponsor usually signs a carve-out guaranty for the mezzanine loan as well as for the senior loan.

Because it is a loan with defined collateral and a negotiated agreement with the senior lender, mezzanine debt is the more standardized of the two products on larger deals.

How preferred equity works

A preferred equity investor buys an ownership stake in the entity that owns the property, directly or one level up. The terms are written into the entity's operating agreement, not into loan documents.

  • Payments: a preferred return on the invested amount, paid before the sponsor receives any distributions. Part is often paid currently and part accrues.
  • Repayment: the investor's capital is returned ahead of the sponsor's, usually by a set redemption date.
  • Remedy: there is no collateral to foreclose on. If the sponsor misses a required payment or the redemption date, the investor's rights are contractual: typically removing the sponsor as manager, taking control of decisions or forcing a sale.
  • Upside: some preferred equity includes a share of profits above the preferred return. Mezzanine loans usually do not.

Preferred equity comes in harder and softer forms. Hard preferred equity has fixed payment dates, a fixed redemption date and strong takeover rights, so it behaves much like debt. Soft preferred equity is paid only when cash is available and has milder remedies. The label matters less than the terms, because lenders and courts look at what the document actually requires.

Mezzanine debt vs. preferred equity side by side

Mezzanine debtPreferred equity
Legal formLoanEquity investment
CollateralPledge of ownership interestsNone; rights under the operating agreement
Main remedyUCC foreclosure on the pledged interestsRemoval of the sponsor and control of the entity
Deal with senior lenderIntercreditor agreementOften none, sometimes a recognition agreement
What the sponsor paysInterestPreferred return
Tax treatment, generallyInterest expenseDistributions to an owner
Senior lender viewMust be approved; some prohibit itSometimes allowed where mezzanine debt is not

Tax and accounting treatment depend on the exact terms and on your own situation, so have your tax adviser review the structure before you sign a term sheet.

What the senior lender will allow

The first question is not which product you prefer. It is what your senior loan permits. Most mortgage documents restrict additional debt, transfers of ownership interests and changes of control, and both gap products touch those clauses.

  • Conduit loans: mezzanine debt is often possible if it is arranged at closing with an intercreditor agreement the senior lender accepts. Adding it later is difficult. See CMBS loans explained.
  • Agency loans: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac limit subordinate financing and have their own rules on which forms of preferred equity are acceptable. See agency multifamily loans.
  • Banks and life companies: policies vary, and many prohibit subordinate financing outright.
  • Bridge and construction lenders: some allow gap capital, and some provide it themselves as part of one combined loan.

Do not try to get around a restriction by calling debt equity. If preferred equity has fixed payments and takeover rights, a senior lender may treat it as prohibited debt. A breach of the transfer or additional-debt covenants is a common full-recourse trigger, as explained in recourse vs. non-recourse loans. Disclose the structure and get written consent.

Cost, coverage and how to choose

Gap capital is priced well above senior debt because it is repaid second. Preferred equity often costs a little more than mezzanine debt for the same position, since its remedies are weaker. Both commonly carry origination fees, and some carry exit fees or a minimum return.

Providers size their piece on combined numbers. Continue the example: the property's NOI is $1.5 million and senior debt service is $900,000, a DSCR of 1.67x. Add $330,000 of mezzanine interest and total payments are $1,230,000, for a combined DSCR of 1.22x. Debt yield falls from 12.5% on the senior loan alone to 10% on the combined $15 million. The cushion that protected the sponsor is now much thinner. Debt yield explained covers that measure.

  • Choose based on what the senior lender permits first.
  • Mezzanine debt tends to fit larger deals where an intercreditor agreement is practical.
  • Preferred equity tends to fit smaller deals and joint ventures, or senior loans that bar mezzanine debt.
  • In either case, read the default and control provisions as carefully as the price.

This is general information, so confirm the terms with each capital provider and your own legal and tax counsel.

Where CREaiD helps

Before you add a layer of capital, test whether the deal can carry it.

With CREaiD you can upload deal data for a quick investment analysis, and use the Lender Matchmaker to describe the deal and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders, including private lenders and private equity.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • Mezzanine debt and preferred equity both sit between the senior loan and the sponsor's common equity.
  • Mezzanine debt is a loan secured by a pledge of ownership interests; preferred equity is an ownership stake with priority distributions.
  • A mezzanine lender forecloses on the pledge, while a preferred equity investor uses control rights in the operating agreement.
  • What the senior lender permits usually decides which one you can use.
  • Size the deal on combined DSCR and debt yield, not on the senior loan alone.

Questions people ask

Is preferred equity debt or equity?

Legally it is equity: an ownership interest with priority over the sponsor's common equity. Economically it can look like debt when it has fixed payments and a required redemption date. Senior lenders and tax advisers look at the actual terms, not the name.

Which is cheaper, mezzanine debt or preferred equity?

For the same position in the capital stack they are priced close together. Preferred equity often costs somewhat more because the investor has no collateral to foreclose on. Fees, accrual features and any profit share can change the comparison, so compare total cost over your expected hold.

Do I need the senior lender's consent?

In nearly all cases, yes. Mezzanine debt needs the senior lender's approval and an intercreditor agreement. Preferred equity may need consent under the loan's transfer and change-of-control clauses, especially if the investor can remove the sponsor.

Can a mezzanine lender take the property?

Not directly. It can foreclose on the ownership interests and become the owner of the entity that holds the property. The senior mortgage stays in place, and the mezzanine lender must keep it current and meet the conditions in the intercreditor agreement.

When does gap capital make sense?

When the property's return on total cost is comfortably above the cost of the gap capital, and the combined payments still leave a cushion. It is a way to stretch equity across more deals or to close a shortfall in a refinance. It is risky when the plan only works if everything goes right.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free