
Why commercial loans have prepayment penalties
A lender that makes a 10-year fixed-rate loan has promised its own investors a stream of interest for 10 years. If you pay off in year four, the lender has to reinvest the money, possibly at a lower rate. The prepayment penalty covers that loss. In exchange for accepting it, you get a lower fixed rate than you would on a freely prepayable loan.
The stronger the lender's promise to its investors, the stricter the penalty. Loans that are pooled and sold as bonds have the most rigid terms. Bank loans held on the bank's own books are usually the most flexible. Floating-rate loans carry lighter penalties because the rate resets with the market, so the lender loses little when you repay. See fixed vs. floating rate commercial loans for that trade-off.
The main types compared
| Type | How the cost is set | Where it is common |
|---|---|---|
| Lockout | No prepayment allowed for a set period | Start of CMBS and some life company loans |
| Yield maintenance | Present value of the interest the lender loses | Agency, life company, CMBS |
| Defeasance | Cost of securities that replace the loan payments | CMBS, some agency loans |
| Step-down | Fixed percent of balance, falling each year | Banks, credit unions, some agency loans |
| Minimum interest | A set number of months of interest | Bridge and private loans |
| Exit fee | Fixed percent of the loan at payoff | Bridge and private loans |
Most fixed-rate loans also have an open period at the end, often the last few months of the term, when you can repay with no penalty. The longer the open period, the easier it is to refinance on your own schedule.
Step-downs: the simplest to price
A step-down penalty is a percentage of the balance you prepay, set by the year in which you pay. A common five-year schedule is written 5-4-3-2-1: 5% in year one, 4% in year two, and so on.
Say you have a $5,000,000 balance and sell in year three of a 5-4-3-2-1 schedule. The penalty is 3% x $5,000,000 = $150,000. In year five it would be $50,000. You know the cost on the day you sign, and it does not move with interest rates.
SBA loans use fixed schedules too. SBA 7(a) loans with a maturity of 15 years or more typically carry a 5%, 3%, 1% penalty in the first three years for large prepayments, and the SBA 504 debenture has a penalty that declines each year over the early part of its term. The guide to SBA 504 vs. SBA 7(a) covers both programs.
Yield maintenance: the cost moves with rates
Yield maintenance makes the lender whole. The penalty is roughly the present value of the difference between your loan rate and the yield on a US Treasury that matures when your loan would have, applied to the balance for the remaining term. Most loans also set a minimum, commonly 1% of the amount prepaid.
A simplified example: you prepay a $5,000,000 interest-only balance with five years left. Your loan rate is 6.0% and the matching Treasury yields a hypothetical 4.0%. The lender loses 2.0% a year, or $100,000 a year for five years. That is $500,000 before discounting. Discounted at the 4.0% Treasury yield, it is worth about $445,000 now. The actual formula in your loan documents uses monthly payments and its own definitions, so the figure will differ, but the size is realistic.
- If Treasury yields fall, the gap widens and the penalty grows. This is when you most want to refinance, and when it costs the most.
- If Treasury yields rise to or above your loan rate, the calculated loss is zero and you pay only the minimum, here 1% x $5,000,000 = $50,000.
- As the loan ages, fewer years remain, so the penalty shrinks toward the minimum.
Yield maintenance is a standard option on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac multifamily loans, which often also offer step-down schedules at a somewhat higher rate.
Defeasance: replacing the collateral
Defeasance is not technically a prepayment. The loan stays in place. You buy a portfolio of government securities whose payments match every remaining payment on your loan, pledge that portfolio to the lender, and the lender releases its lien on the property. The bondholders keep receiving exactly what they were promised.
The cost is the price of the securities minus your loan balance, plus fees. Like yield maintenance, it rises when Treasury yields are below your loan rate, because you need more bonds to produce the same payments. When yields are above your loan rate, the securities can cost less than the balance. You also pay several third parties to carry out the transaction, including a consultant, attorneys, an accountant and a successor borrower, and those fees can run into the tens of thousands of dollars even on a small loan. The process takes about a month, so plan it into a sale timeline.
Defeasance is most closely tied to conduit lending. The guide to CMBS loans explains why those loans are built this way.
Bridge loans: minimum interest and exit fees
Short-term floating-rate loans handle early payoff differently. A lender that spends weeks closing a loan does not want it repaid in three months, so it sets a minimum amount of interest it must earn.
Say a $4,000,000 bridge loan at a hypothetical 9% rate has 12 months of minimum interest. Monthly interest is $4,000,000 x 9% / 12 = $30,000. If you pay off after eight months, you owe the remaining four months: 4 x $30,000 = $120,000. A 1% exit fee adds $40,000 whenever you repay. The guide to commercial bridge loans covers these terms along with extension fees.
How to choose, and where CREaiD helps
- Match the penalty to your plan. If you will hold to maturity, take the lowest rate and accept yield maintenance or defeasance. If you may sell in a few years, pay a little more in rate for a step-down or a shorter term.
- Ask whether the loan is assumable. A buyer who takes over your loan, for an assumption fee, avoids the penalty entirely.
- Price it before you sign. Ask the lender for a sample calculation at a few payoff dates, and put the result next to the rate when you compare term sheets.
- Negotiate the open period. A longer penalty-free window at the end costs the lender little and can save you a lot.
Prepayment terms differ sharply between banks, agency lenders, CMBS and private lenders. CREaiD's Lender Matchmaker lets you describe your deal, including how long you plan to hold, and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders.
Prepayment formulas are defined in the loan documents, so confirm the exact terms with the lender and your own counsel.
Key takeaways
- Fixed-rate commercial loans charge for early payoff because the lender has promised investors a stream of interest.
- Step-downs are fixed percentages you can price on day one.
- Yield maintenance and defeasance cost more when Treasury yields are below your loan rate.
- Bridge loans use minimum interest and exit fees instead.
- Choose the prepayment structure that matches how long you expect to hold the property.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper, yield maintenance or defeasance?
The interest-rate cost of the two is usually close, because both are driven by the gap between your loan rate and Treasury yields. Defeasance adds third-party fees but can come out cheaper when Treasury yields are above your loan rate, since yield maintenance normally has a 1% minimum. Get both quoted if your loan allows a choice.
Can I negotiate a prepayment penalty?
On bank and life company loans, often yes, usually in exchange for a slightly higher rate. On CMBS and agency loans the structures are standard, but you can often choose between available options and ask for a longer open period.
Does a prepayment penalty apply if I sell the property?
Yes. A sale pays off the loan, which triggers the penalty unless the buyer assumes the loan. Many fixed-rate commercial loans are assumable with lender approval and a fee, which can make a property with a low-rate loan easier to sell.
What is a lockout period?
A lockout is a period, usually at the start of the loan, when prepayment is not allowed at all. After it ends, defeasance or yield maintenance applies. If you might sell early, check the lockout length before anything else.
Do partial prepayments trigger a penalty?
It depends on the loan. Many bank loans allow a limited amount of extra principal each year without penalty. CMBS and agency loans generally do not allow partial prepayment at all.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
