
What is the actual difference between a bank and a credit union?
A bank is owned by shareholders and lends to earn them a profit. A credit union is owned by its members, the people and businesses that keep accounts there, and does not have outside shareholders. To borrow from a credit union you first have to join, which usually means living, working or owning a business in its area, or belonging to a group it serves. Joining is normally quick and cheap.
Both take deposits and lend them out, and both keep most of their commercial real estate loans on their own books. A loan kept on the lender's books is called a portfolio loan. That matters to you because a portfolio lender can bend its own guidelines for a deal it likes, while a lender that sells its loans has to follow the buyer's rules exactly.
The rules they answer to are different. Banks have a legal limit on how much they can lend to one borrower, tied to the bank's capital. Credit unions have that kind of limit too, and most also face a federal cap on the total business lending they can hold relative to their size. In practice, both limits mean a small institution has a ceiling on the loan it can make by itself.
Bank vs. credit union: side by side
| Feature | Bank | Credit union |
|---|---|---|
| Who can borrow | Anyone in its market | Members only, joining is usually simple |
| Loan size | From small to very large, depending on the bank | Often smaller, larger loans shared with other credit unions |
| Prepayment penalty | Common, often a step-down over the first years | Often none or light |
| Personal guarantee | Usual | Usual, and often required by regulation |
| Construction and complex deals | Widely available | Offered by some, less common |
| Deposit relationship | Often expected | Membership account required |
| Decision making | Loan officer plus credit committee | Loan officer plus credit committee, sometimes an outside servicing company |
Treat the table as tendencies, not rules. A large credit union with a strong commercial team can act more like a regional bank than a small community bank does. Always ask the specific lender.
When is a credit union the better choice?
- You may sell or refinance early. Federally chartered credit unions generally cannot charge prepayment penalties, and many state-chartered ones charge little. If your plan is to improve the property and refinance in three years, that freedom has real value.
- The loan is small and plain. A stabilized small apartment building, a retail strip or a building your own business occupies, in the credit union's home area, is the center of what credit unions want.
- You are already a member. Your history of deposits and payments is in front of the people making the decision.
- You want a longer fixed period. Some credit unions offer fixed rates for longer than local banks do. Ask, because this varies widely.
The limits are real too. Many credit unions do not make construction loans, lend only close to home, and want a full personal guarantee from every owner with a significant share. Some send their commercial loans to an outside servicing organization for underwriting, which can add a step and some time.
When is a bank the better choice?
- The loan is large. A bigger bank can hold a loan that would exceed a small credit union's limit, without having to bring in partners.
- You need construction or renovation money. Banks are the main source of commercial construction loans, with staff who manage draws and inspections.
- Your structure is complicated. Several partners, several entities, properties in more than one state or a line of credit alongside the mortgage are routine for a commercial bank.
- Your business banks there. A bank that holds your operating accounts sees your cash flow daily and often prices the loan with the whole relationship in mind.
- You want an SBA loan. Many banks have dedicated SBA teams for buildings your own business will occupy. Some credit unions do as well.
The usual cost of a bank loan is the prepayment penalty and the expectation that your deposits move to the bank. Both are negotiable more often than borrowers assume, especially when you bring a strong deal and a second quote. Whether a small local bank or a large one fits better is a separate question, covered in local bank vs. national lender.
A worked example: what a prepayment penalty is worth
Rate is the first thing borrowers compare, and it is often the wrong place to stop. Here is a hypothetical comparison with round numbers.
Say you need a $2,000,000 loan on a small office building. A bank and a credit union both offer 75% loan-to-value and a five-year fixed rate. The bank's rate is 0.25% lower. The bank charges a step-down prepayment penalty of 5% of the balance in year one, 4% in year two, 3% in year three, 2% in year four and 1% in year five. The credit union charges none.
- The bank's rate saving. 0.25% of $2,000,000 is about $5,000 a year. Over three years that is about $15,000.
- The bank's penalty if you sell in year three. By then the balance is about $1,900,000. 3% of $1,900,000 is $57,000.
- Net result. $57,000 minus $15,000 = $42,000. Selling in year three costs about $42,000 more with the bank loan.
- If you hold all five years. There is no penalty at maturity, so the bank's lower rate saves about $25,000 over the term.
So the answer depends on your plan. If you are sure you will hold to maturity, take the lower rate. If there is a fair chance of a sale or refinance, the loan with no penalty is cheaper. The types of penalties and how to negotiate them are in commercial loan prepayment penalties.
How to choose between the two
Do not choose by category. Choose by evidence that the specific lender wants your loan. These steps work for both:
- List the banks and credit unions with offices near the property, plus any where you already keep accounts.
- Check which of them actually make your kind of loan. Regulatory reports show how much apartment, commercial and construction lending each institution holds, and public loan records show who closed loans in your county. See how to use public loan data to find the right lender.
- Call the commercial lending department, not the branch, and ask about property type, county, loan size, loan-to-value, coverage ratio and guarantee.
- Send the same loan request to two or three banks and one or two credit unions on the same day.
- Compare the written offers line by line: loan amount, rate and fixed period, amortization, fees, prepayment penalty, guarantee and deposit requirements.
Getting quotes from both kinds of lender also helps you negotiate. A bank that knows a credit union has offered no prepayment penalty will often soften its own. How to read the offers is in how to compare term sheets, and the wider field of lenders is in types of commercial real estate lenders.
Common mistakes when comparing banks and credit unions
A few wrong assumptions lead borrowers to skip a lender that would have given them the better loan:
- Assuming credit unions only make car loans and home mortgages. Many have full commercial real estate teams.
- Assuming a credit union is always cheaper. Pricing depends on the institution and the deal. Get the quote.
- Comparing rates on different fixed periods. A five-year fixed rate and a ten-year fixed rate are different products.
- Forgetting the reset. Ask what happens when the fixed period ends: a new rate by formula, a balloon payment, or both.
- Ignoring the deposit requirement. Moving your operating accounts has a cost in time and sometimes in fees.
- Talking to the branch. Branch staff rarely handle commercial real estate. Ask for a commercial loan officer by title.
Where CREaiD helps you compare
CREaiD is a lender search for commercial real estate loans built on public loan records, covering more than 7,000 banks, credit unions, mortgage lenders, SBA lenders, private lenders and funds. In Find Lenders you pick the state, the kind of loan and the loan amount and see the lenders that made that kind of loan there, banks and credit unions together, so your short list starts from lending activity and not from advertising. It has a free version.
Loan terms and membership rules differ by institution, so confirm every term in writing with the lender and review the documents with your own counsel.
Key takeaways
- Banks and credit unions make similar commercial real estate loans, and both usually require a personal guarantee.
- Credit unions often charge little or no prepayment penalty, which matters most if you may sell or refinance early.
- Banks are usually stronger for large loans, construction and complicated borrowers.
- A lower rate can cost more than a loan with no penalty if you leave before maturity, so match the loan to your plan.
- Choose the specific lender that already makes your kind of loan in your county, and get quotes from both kinds.
Questions people ask
Do credit unions make commercial real estate loans?
Yes. Many credit unions lend on apartment buildings, retail, office, industrial and owner-occupied buildings, usually in their home area. They call these member business loans. Smaller credit unions may share a larger loan with other credit unions.
Are credit union commercial loan rates lower than bank rates?
Sometimes. Credit unions do not have outside shareholders, and some pass that on in pricing, but a bank that wants your deposits may match or beat it. The only reliable answer is to get written quotes from both on the same day.
Do you have to be a member to get a credit union commercial loan?
Yes, the borrower has to be a member before the loan closes. Membership is usually based on where you live or work or where the business is located, and joining normally takes a small deposit. Ask about eligibility on the first call.
Do credit unions charge prepayment penalties on commercial loans?
Federally chartered credit unions generally cannot. State-chartered credit unions follow their state's rules and some do charge them, usually lighter than a bank's. Ask for the prepayment terms in writing.
Is it easier to get approved at a bank or a credit union?
Neither is easier as a category. Approval depends on whether your property type, location and loan size fit what that institution likes to hold. A lender that has closed many loans like yours approves faster than one that has closed none.
Can you get a non-recourse loan from a bank or credit union?
Rarely. Most bank and credit union commercial real estate loans carry a personal guarantee, although strong borrowers with low loan-to-value sometimes negotiate a partial one. Non-recourse loans come mainly from agency, CMBS and life company lenders.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
