Preview of the new creaid.ai. Not live yet. Yellow = to confirm with you.

Underwriting and numbers · 10 min read

How Commercial Loan Interest Rates Are Set

Short answer

A commercial loan interest rate is built from two parts: an index plus a spread. The index is a public benchmark rate that moves with the market, such as a Treasury yield, SOFR or the Prime Rate. The spread is the lender's markup for risk, cost and profit, and it depends on the property, the loan terms and the borrower. You cannot change the index, but you can influence the spread and choose when to lock.

A commercial bank building
A commercial bank building. Example photo: Joe Mabel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What is the formula behind a commercial loan rate?

Almost every commercial real estate loan is priced the same way: rate = index + spread.

  • The index is a benchmark that nobody in your deal controls. It reflects what money costs in the wider market on a given day. It is published, so you can look it up yourself.
  • The spread (also called the margin) is the amount the lender adds on top. It is quoted in percentage points or in basis points. One basis point is one hundredth of a percentage point, so 200 basis points is 2.00%.

Here is the math with invented numbers that are not market levels. If the index is at 4.00% and the lender's spread is 2.00%, your rate is 6.00%. If the index rises to 4.50% before you lock, the same spread gives you 6.50%. Your deal did not get worse. The market moved.

Some banks quote a single rate without showing the parts. The formula is still underneath it: the bank starts with its own cost of money for the term you want and adds a margin.

Which index does each type of loan use?

Loan typeUsual indexFixed or floating
Agency apartment loans (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac)Treasury yield that matches the loan termMostly fixed, floating available
CMBS and life insurance company loansTreasury yields or swap rates for the loan termFixed
Bank and credit union loansThe bank's cost of funds, Treasury yields, Prime or SOFRFixed for a few years, or floating
SBA 7(a)Most often the Prime Rate, within program limits on the spreadUsually floating, sometimes fixed
SBA 504Bank portion priced by the bank; development company portion set when its bonds are soldDevelopment company portion is fixed
Bridge and construction loansSOFR, sometimes PrimeFloating
Private and hard money loansOften no index, the lender sets a flat rateFixed for a short term

A few definitions. A Treasury yield is the return investors earn on United States government debt of a given length, such as five or ten years. SOFR (the Secured Overnight Financing Rate) is a benchmark for very short-term borrowing, used for floating-rate loans. The Prime Rate is a base rate banks use for business loans, and it moves when the Federal Reserve changes its target rate. A swap rate is the market price of trading a floating rate for a fixed one for a set term.

Fixed-rate loans follow longer-term benchmarks. Floating-rate loans follow short-term ones, and they reset, often monthly. The choice between them is covered in fixed vs. floating rate commercial loans.

What decides the spread?

The spread is the lender's price for the risk of your specific loan, plus its costs and profit. Lower risk means a lower spread. The main inputs:

  • Loan-to-value (LTV). The loan divided by the property's value. A 60% loan is priced better than a 75% loan.
  • Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR). Net operating income divided by annual loan payments. More coverage, lower spread. See DSCR explained.
  • Property type and quality. Apartments and industrial buildings usually price tightest. Hotels, older offices and special-purpose buildings price wider.
  • Location. Large, active markets generally get better pricing than small or shrinking ones.
  • Tenants and leases. Long leases with strong tenants lower the risk of the income.
  • Loan size and term. Very small loans often carry a higher spread, because the work to make them is the same. Longer fixed terms can cost more.
  • Recourse. A personal guarantee can lower a bank's rate. Non-recourse debt often costs more. See recourse vs. non-recourse commercial loans.
  • Prepayment flexibility. The freedom to pay off early without a penalty usually costs a higher rate. See commercial loan prepayment penalties.
  • The borrower. Experience, net worth, cash and credit history.
  • The lender's own position. Its cost of money, how much it wants this kind of loan right now, and how many other lenders are competing for it.

The last item explains why two lenders can quote different rates on the same deal on the same day. That is the reason to collect more than one quote.

A worked example: what a half point does

All figures here are invented for illustration. Say you want a $2,000,000 loan. The index is 4.00% and Lender A quotes a spread of 2.00%, for a rate of 6.00%. Interest in the first year is about $120,000 (6.00% of $2,000,000).

  • If the index rises half a point before you lock, the rate becomes 6.50% and first-year interest is about $130,000. That is $10,000 more per year.
  • If Lender B quotes a spread of 2.50% on the same day, the result is the same 6.50%. A half point of spread costs exactly what a half point of index costs.

A higher rate also shrinks the loan you qualify for. Suppose the property has $200,000 of net operating income and the lender requires a 1.25x DSCR. The most you can pay per year is $200,000 divided by 1.25, or $160,000. With 25-year amortization, annual payments are about 7.73% of the loan at a 6.00% rate, and about 8.10% at 6.50%.

  • At 6.00%: $160,000 divided by 0.0773 is a maximum loan of about $2,070,000.
  • At 6.50%: $160,000 divided by 0.0810 is a maximum loan of about $1,975,000.
  • Difference: about $95,000 less loan from a half-point move.

So the rate affects two things at once: what you pay and how much you can borrow. The sizing math is in how to size a commercial loan.

When is the rate locked, and what are floors and caps?

A quote is not a locked rate. Until the lock, the spread is usually held and the index floats, so your final rate moves with the market.

  • Rate lock. The moment the lender fixes your rate. Agency and CMBS loans typically lock shortly before closing, after approval. Some lenders offer an early lock at application for a deposit or a fee. Banks often set the rate at commitment or a few days before closing. Ask every lender: when does the rate lock, and what does it cost?
  • Index floor. A minimum on the index or on the whole rate. With invented numbers: a floating loan priced at SOFR plus 3.00% with a 4.50% floor on the index is at 8.00% when SOFR is 5.00%. If SOFR falls to 4.00%, the rate stops at 7.50%, not 7.00%.
  • Interest rate cap. An agreement you buy that limits how high the index can go for you. Many floating-rate bridge lenders require one. If the cap is set at 6.00% on the index and the index goes to 7.00%, your rate on a 3.00% spread is held at 9.00%, not 10.00%.
  • Swap. Some banks make a floating-rate loan and pair it with a swap that turns your payments into a fixed rate. Ending a swap early can cost money or pay money, depending on where rates are.
  • Buying the rate down. Some lenders let you pay an extra fee at closing in exchange for a lower rate.

How to compare two rate quotes fairly

  1. Ask for the index, the spread and the date of the quote. Two quotes taken a week apart are not comparable until you adjust for the index.
  2. Add the fees. A rough method is to spread the up-front fee over the years you expect to hold the loan.
  3. Check how interest is calculated. Many commercial loans use an actual/360 method, which charges slightly more interest per year than a 30/360 method at the same stated rate.
  4. Compare the terms that come with the rate: amortization, interest-only period, prepayment terms, recourse and reserves.
  5. Ask about floors, caps and lock timing on any floating-rate quote and any quote that is not locked yet.

An example with invented numbers on a $2,000,000 loan held five years. Quote A is 6.00% with a 1% origination fee ($20,000). Quote B is 6.15% with no fee. Quote A costs about $120,000 a year in interest plus $4,000 a year of fee ($20,000 divided by 5), or $124,000. Quote B costs about $123,000 a year. The lower rate is the more expensive loan. A full method is in how to compare commercial loan term sheets.

What can you do to get a lower rate?

The index is out of your hands. Everything on this list works on the spread.

  • Borrow a little less. Dropping LTV by 5 to 10 points often moves you to a better pricing tier. Ask for quotes at two loan amounts.
  • Improve the income before you apply. Renew leases, fill vacancies and clean up expenses.
  • Approach lenders that want your kind of loan. A lender active in your property type and area prices more sharply than one making an exception.
  • Get several quotes on the same day with the same package.
  • Consider recourse or a shorter fixed period if the savings are worth the trade.
  • Accept a prepayment penalty if you are sure you will hold the loan for the term.
  • Bring deposits to a bank that values the relationship.

Where CREaiD helps with pricing

Spreads follow loan-to-value and debt coverage, so know those numbers before you ask for a quote. CREaiD's deal check shows loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield from the value, the loan, the income and the rate you type in, and tells you what is weak. The lender search, built on public loan records, shows lenders that made that kind of loan in your state at your loan amount, so you can ask several fitting lenders for quotes at once. It has a free version.

Rates, spreads and lock terms change daily and differ by lender, so confirm every figure in writing with the lender and review the loan documents with your own counsel.

Brian Gramlich
About the author

Brian Gramlich is the CEO and founder of Terrydale Capital, a commercial real estate finance firm based in Dallas, Texas, and the founder of CREaiD.

Key takeaways

  • A commercial loan rate is an index plus a spread, and the two parts move for different reasons.
  • Fixed-rate loans usually follow Treasury yields or swap rates, and floating-rate loans follow SOFR or Prime.
  • The spread depends on LTV, DSCR, property type, loan terms, the borrower and the lender's own appetite.
  • A quote is not locked, so ask when the rate locks, what it costs and whether a floor or cap applies.
  • Compare quotes by index, spread, fees and terms together, because the lowest stated rate is not always the cheapest loan.

Questions people ask

What index are commercial real estate loans based on?

It depends on the loan. Long-term fixed-rate loans from agency, CMBS and life insurance company lenders usually follow Treasury yields or swap rates for the same term. Floating-rate bridge and construction loans usually follow SOFR, and many bank and SBA 7(a) loans follow the Prime Rate.

Why are commercial loan rates higher than home mortgage rates?

Commercial loans are repaid from a property's income, which is less predictable than a household's, and they are larger, less standardized and more work to underwrite. Lenders charge a wider spread for that risk and cost. There is also less government support behind most commercial loans than behind home mortgages.

Can you negotiate the interest rate on a commercial loan?

You can negotiate the spread and the fees, not the index. The best tools are a competing written quote, a lower loan amount, a stronger guarantee or deposits with the bank. Lenders have more room to move on a clean deal they want than on a marginal one.

What is a spread on a commercial loan?

The spread is the amount the lender adds to the index to arrive at your rate. It covers the risk of the loan, the lender's costs and its profit. It is often quoted in basis points, where 100 basis points equal 1.00%.

When should you lock the rate on a commercial loan?

You can lock only when the lender allows it, commonly after approval and shortly before closing, though some lenders offer an early lock for a deposit or fee. Locking early removes the risk of a rising index and gives up the benefit if it falls. Decide based on how much a higher rate would hurt the deal, not on a forecast.

Find lenders for your deal in minutes

CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.

Start free