
What is a cash-out refinance on a commercial property?
A cash-out refinance turns part of your equity (the property's value minus what you owe) into cash without selling the building. The new lender pays off the old loan, pays the closing costs, and wires the rest to you. You keep the property, the tenants and any future appreciation. In exchange, you carry a bigger loan and a bigger payment.
Lenders separate two kinds of refinance. A rate-and-term refinance only replaces the old balance and covers costs. A cash-out refinance puts money in the owner's pocket. Lenders see cash-out as a little riskier, because the owner has less of their own money left in the property, so the terms are often slightly tighter. The general process is the same and is covered in how to refinance a commercial property.
How much cash can you take out?
Two limits decide the new loan amount, and the lower one wins.
- The value limit. Loan-to-value (LTV) is the loan divided by the appraised value. For cash-out, lenders commonly cap LTV at 65% to 75%, often about 5 points lower than they allow on a purchase or a rate-and-term refinance.
- The income limit. The debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) is net operating income divided by annual loan payments. Lenders commonly want 1.20x to 1.35x. A bigger loan has a bigger payment, so income often caps the loan before value does.
- Debt yield. Some lenders, especially CMBS lenders, also require net operating income to be a minimum percentage of the loan amount.
The cash you receive is the new loan amount minus the old loan payoff, minus any prepayment penalty, minus closing costs and any reserves the new lender collects. The income test is explained in DSCR explained.
A worked example with round numbers
Say you own a warehouse worth $5,000,000 that produces $350,000 of net operating income (NOI). The existing loan balance is $2,000,000. A lender offers cash-out up to 70% LTV with a 1.25x minimum DSCR. Use a hypothetical 6.5% rate with 25-year amortization, where annual payments are about $81,000 for every $1,000,000 borrowed.
- Value limit: 70% of $5,000,000 is $3,500,000.
- Income limit: $350,000 divided by 1.25 is $280,000 of allowed annual payments. $280,000 divided by 0.081 is about $3,456,000. Round down to $3,450,000.
- New loan: the lower figure, $3,450,000. Income, not value, set the limit.
- Minus the old loan payoff: $2,000,000.
- Minus a 1% prepayment fee on the old loan: $20,000.
- Minus closing costs on the new loan: $70,000.
- Cash to you: $3,450,000 minus $2,000,000 minus $20,000 minus $70,000 is $1,360,000.
Now look at what it does to cash flow. Suppose the old loan cost $165,000 a year. The property earned $350,000 and kept $185,000 after debt payments. The new $3,450,000 loan costs about $279,500 a year (3.45 times $81,000). The property now keeps about $70,500. You took out $1,360,000 and gave up about $114,500 a year of cash flow. Whether that is a good trade depends on what the cash earns where you put it next.
What do lenders want to know about the cash?
Expect the question: what is the money for? Most lenders are comfortable when the cash goes back into real estate or the business. Common uses they see as reasonable:
- A down payment on another property
- Renovations, a new roof or tenant improvements at this property
- Paying off more expensive debt, such as a second loan or a partner loan
- Buying out a partner
- Working capital for the business that occupies the building
Lenders also look at how long you have owned the property. This is called seasoning. Many banks and agency lenders want to see roughly six to twelve months of ownership before they lend on a new, higher appraised value. Before that, some will only lend against your original cost. Bridge and private lenders are usually more flexible, at a higher price.
They will also check you. A cash-out loan often comes with a closer look at your net worth, your cash after closing and your other properties. See net worth and liquidity requirements for commercial loans.
Cash-out refinance compared with the alternatives
| Option | How it works | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Cash-out refinance | One new, larger first loan replaces the old one | You give up the old loan's rate and may pay a prepayment penalty |
| Second loan or mezzanine debt | The old first loan stays, a second loan sits behind it | Higher rate on the second piece, and the first lender often must consent |
| Line of credit secured by the property | Draw and repay as needed, usually from a bank | Usually a floating rate, shorter term and full recourse |
| Bringing in an equity partner | A partner pays you for a share of ownership | No new debt, but you share future income and control |
| Selling the property | You receive all the equity | You lose the asset and may owe tax on the gain |
If your existing loan has a low fixed rate and a costly prepayment formula, keeping it and adding a second layer can be cheaper than replacing it. Compare the blended cost of both pieces with the cost of one new loan. The structures are explained in mezzanine debt vs. preferred equity, and the exit costs in commercial loan prepayment penalties.
Risks and common mistakes
Taking cash out raises your debt and lowers your cushion. Most of the trouble comes from a short list of avoidable errors.
- Taking the maximum. A loan sized right at the minimum DSCR leaves no cushion. One vacancy can push the property below break-even.
- Counting on the appraisal. The cash-out amount depends on the appraised value. If the appraisal comes in 10% lower than you expected, the value limit drops by the same share.
- Forgetting the exit cost of the old loan. Get a written payoff statement, including the prepayment fee, before you compare offers.
- Ignoring the new loan's terms. A floating rate, a short term or a personal guarantee can cost more than the cash is worth. Read recourse vs. non-recourse commercial loans before you sign a guarantee.
- Not planning the use of the money. Cash sitting in an account while you pay interest on it is a loss. Line up the next purchase or project first.
- Assuming the tax result. Loan proceeds are generally treated differently from sale proceeds, but the rules depend on your situation. Ask your tax adviser before closing.
How to prepare for a cash-out refinance
A few hours of preparation tells you the likely loan amount and the net cash before any lender is involved.
- Get a payoff statement and read the prepayment terms on the existing loan.
- Update the rent roll and the trailing twelve months of income and expenses. Fix anything that does not tie together.
- Estimate value honestly. Divide NOI by a realistic capitalization rate for your property type and market, and see cap rates and how lenders use them.
- Run both limits (LTV and DSCR) yourself, the way the example above does, so you know the likely loan amount before a lender tells you.
- Write one paragraph on what the cash is for. Lenders will ask.
- Send the same package to several lenders that are active in your property type, state and loan size, and compare the net cash to you, not only the rate.
Where CREaiD helps with a cash-out refinance
CREaiD's deal check lets you type the value, the loan, the income and the rate and see loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield, plus what is weak. You can try different loan amounts until you find the largest one the income supports. The lender search is built on public loan records, so you can pick the state, the kind of loan and the loan amount and see lenders that made that kind of loan there. It has a free version.
Cash-out limits, seasoning rules and prepayment terms differ by lender, so confirm them in writing with the lender and review the loan documents with your own counsel and tax adviser before you commit.
Key takeaways
- A cash-out refinance replaces your loan with a larger one and pays you the difference after the payoff, penalties and closing costs.
- Lenders commonly cap cash-out at 65% to 75% of value, and the income test often limits the loan before the value test does.
- In the example, a $3,450,000 loan on a $5,000,000 property produced $1,360,000 of cash and cut annual cash flow by about $114,500.
- Lenders ask what the cash is for and how long you have owned the property, so have clear answers ready.
- Compare a cash-out refinance with a second loan or an equity partner when your existing loan has a low rate or a costly prepayment penalty.
Questions people ask
How much equity do you need for a commercial cash-out refinance?
Lenders commonly allow a cash-out loan of 65% to 75% of appraised value, so you need to keep at least 25% to 35% equity after the new loan. If your current loan is already near that level, there is little or no cash to take. The property's income must also cover the larger payment, usually at 1.20x to 1.35x.
Is cash from a commercial cash-out refinance taxable?
Loan proceeds are generally not treated as income when you receive them, because you have to pay them back. But there are exceptions and later consequences that depend on how you own the property and how you use the money. Ask your tax adviser before you close.
How soon after buying a commercial property can you do a cash-out refinance?
It depends on the lender. Many banks and agency lenders want about six to twelve months of ownership before they will lend on a new, higher appraised value. Bridge and private lenders are often willing sooner, at a higher rate and with more fees.
Are rates higher on a commercial cash-out refinance?
Sometimes. Many lenders price a cash-out loan the same as any other refinance at the same loan-to-value, and others add a small premium or lower the maximum loan-to-value. The bigger effect usually comes from the larger loan amount, because a higher loan-to-value and a lower DSCR are priced as more risk.
Can you use a cash-out refinance to buy another property?
Yes, and it is one of the most common uses. Lenders generally like to see the money stay in real estate. Keep in mind that the lender on the next purchase will count the new, larger payment on the first property when it reviews your overall finances.
What is the difference between a cash-out refinance and a second mortgage on a commercial property?
A cash-out refinance pays off the first loan and replaces it with one larger loan. A second mortgage or mezzanine loan leaves the first loan in place and adds a smaller, more expensive loan behind it. The second route can be cheaper overall when the first loan has a low rate or a large prepayment penalty, but the first lender usually has to approve it.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
