
When does it make sense to refinance a commercial property?
Most commercial loans do not run until they are paid off. They have a term (often 5, 7 or 10 years) that is shorter than the amortization (the schedule the payments are based on, often 25 or 30 years). At the end of the term the remaining balance comes due in one piece, called a balloon payment. So most commercial owners refinance because they have to, not because they want to.
The common reasons to refinance are:
- The loan is maturing. The balloon is due and you need a new loan to pay it.
- A bridge or construction loan has done its job. The property is leased and stable, and it now qualifies for cheaper long-term debt. See how to exit a bridge loan.
- You want a lower payment. A lower rate, a longer amortization or an interest-only period would improve cash flow.
- You want to take equity out. The property is worth more than when you borrowed, and you want cash for another purchase or for improvements. That is a cash-out refinance.
- You want different terms. For example, moving from a floating rate to a fixed rate, removing a personal guarantee, or buying out a partner.
A refinance you choose only makes sense when the benefit is larger than the cost of leaving the old loan and closing the new one. That math is in the worked example below.
What do you check before you call a lender?
Read your existing loan documents first. Three items decide your timing and your cost.
- Maturity date and extension options. Know the exact date the balloon is due, and whether the loan lets you extend if you meet certain tests.
- Prepayment terms. Many commercial loans charge a fee if you pay them off early. It can be a simple percentage that steps down each year, or a formula such as yield maintenance or defeasance, which can be expensive when rates have fallen. The details are in commercial loan prepayment penalties. Many loans have an open window near maturity with no penalty.
- The payoff amount. Ask your lender for a written payoff statement. It shows principal, accrued interest, any penalty and any fees.
Then look at the property the way a new lender will. Pull the current rent roll (the list of tenants, rents and lease dates) and the trailing twelve months of income and expenses. A lender sizes the new loan on what the property earns now, not on what it earned when you bought it and not on what you hope it will earn next year.
How do lenders size a refinance loan?
A lender runs up to three tests and lends the smallest result. Each test starts from net operating income (NOI), which is rent and other income minus operating expenses, before loan payments.
| Test | What it measures | Common requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Loan-to-value (LTV) | Loan amount divided by appraised value | Commonly 65% to 75%, up to 80% on some apartment loans |
| Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) | NOI divided by annual loan payments | Commonly 1.20x to 1.35x, depending on property type |
| Debt yield | NOI divided by loan amount | Used mostly by CMBS and larger lenders, often 8% to 10% or more |
When interest rates are higher than they were when you took the old loan, the DSCR test usually decides the loan amount. Higher rates mean higher payments, so the same income supports a smaller loan. Each test is explained in how to size a commercial loan.
A worked example: will the new loan cover the old one?
Say you own a small retail center. It is worth $4,000,000 and produces $300,000 of NOI. The old loan has a balance of $2,400,000 and matures in eight months. The prepayment fee is 1% of the balance, which is $24,000, and you estimate $56,000 of closing costs on the new loan. You need $2,400,000 + $24,000 + $56,000 = $2,480,000 to refinance without bringing cash.
Now run the tests, using a hypothetical 7% rate and 25-year amortization. At those terms, annual payments are about $84,800 for every $1,000,000 borrowed, so a $2,480,000 loan costs about $210,300 a year.
- LTV: $2,480,000 divided by $4,000,000 is 62%. That is inside a 70% limit.
- DSCR: $300,000 divided by $210,300 is about 1.43x. That is above a 1.25x minimum.
- Result: the property supports the loan you need.
Change one fact. Suppose a tenant left and NOI is $240,000. At a 1.25x minimum, the most the lender will allow in annual payments is $240,000 divided by 1.25, or $192,000. That supports a loan of about $2,264,000 ($192,000 divided by 0.0848). You need $2,480,000, so you are short by about $216,000. You would have to bring that cash to closing, lease the space first, or find a different loan structure. This is called a cash-in refinance, and it is the main reason to test your numbers early.
For a refinance you choose, do a break-even check. If the new loan cuts your annual payments from $242,000 to $210,000, you save $32,000 a year. With $80,000 of total costs, the break-even is $80,000 divided by $32,000, or 2.5 years. If you plan to sell in two years, the refinance loses money.
The refinance process, step by step
- Set the goal. Lowest payment, most proceeds, longest fixed term or no personal guarantee. You rarely get all four, so rank them.
- Build the package. Rent roll, trailing twelve months and two or three years of operating statements, a short property summary, a personal financial statement and a schedule of real estate owned. The full list is in what lenders want to see in a commercial loan request package.
- Pick lenders that make this loan. Include your existing lender. It already knows the property and may renew or modify the loan with less cost. Then add three to five lenders that are active in your property type, location and loan size.
- Compare written quotes. Look at loan amount, rate, term, amortization, fees, prepayment terms, recourse and reserves, not the rate alone.
- Sign the term sheet and pay the deposit. The lender orders the appraisal and other third-party reports.
- Underwriting and approval. The lender verifies income, reviews leases, checks your finances and issues a commitment.
- Closing. The title company pays off the old loan from the new loan's proceeds, records the release of the old lien and records the new one. You receive or pay the difference.
A typical bank or agency refinance takes about 45 to 90 days from a signed term sheet. The appraisal is usually the slowest piece. The full schedule is in how long it takes to close a commercial real estate loan.
What does a commercial refinance cost?
Expect two groups of costs: the cost of leaving the old loan and the cost of closing the new one.
- Prepayment penalty or exit fee on the old loan, if you pay it off before the open window.
- Lender origination fee, commonly around 0.5% to 1% of the loan amount on bank loans, and often more on bridge and private loans.
- Appraisal, environmental report and property condition report.
- Title insurance, recording fees and, in some states, mortgage taxes.
- Legal fees, usually both your attorney and the lender's attorney.
- A broker fee, if you use a commercial mortgage broker.
- New reserves. The new lender may collect deposits for taxes, insurance, repairs or tenant improvements at closing.
All of these are covered in commercial loan closing costs and fees. Ask each lender for a written estimate of total costs before you sign, and add the old lender's payoff statement to it.
Common mistakes that delay or shrink a refinance
Most refinance problems are visible months ahead. These are the ones that cost borrowers time or loan dollars.
- Starting too late. With 60 days left you have no room for a low appraisal or a slow report, and lenders know it.
- Assuming the old loan amount will be available again. If rates are higher or income is lower, the new loan can be smaller than the balance.
- Ignoring lease rollover. If a large tenant's lease ends within a year or two of closing, the lender may reduce the income it counts or hold back reserves. Renew key leases before you apply when you can.
- Messy financials. Statements that do not match the rent roll or the tax return lead to questions, and questions cost weeks.
- Forgetting the prepayment penalty. A refinance that looks good on rate can lose money once the exit cost is added.
- Asking only one lender. Even if you stay with your current bank, a second and third quote tell you whether the renewal offer is fair.
Where CREaiD helps with a refinance
CREaiD has a deal check where you type the value, the loan, the income and the rate and see loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield, what is weak, and a one-page loan request. That lets you find out early whether the new loan will cover the old one. Its lender search is built on public loan records: you pick the state, the kind of loan and the loan amount and see lenders that made that kind of loan there. It has a free version.
Loan terms and payoff figures differ by lender and by loan, so confirm every number in writing with the lender and review the documents with your own counsel before you commit.
Key takeaways
- Start a refinance six to twelve months before the loan matures, and read the prepayment terms before anything else.
- The new loan is sized on current income and value, and the lender lends the smallest result of the LTV, DSCR and debt yield tests.
- When rates are higher than on the old loan, DSCR usually limits the loan, and you may need to bring cash to closing.
- Add the old loan's exit cost to the new loan's closing costs and check the break-even before you refinance by choice.
- Ask your existing lender and three to five other fitting lenders for written quotes, and compare all terms, not the rate alone.
Questions people ask
How long does it take to refinance a commercial property?
Most bank and agency refinances take about 45 to 90 days from a signed term sheet to funding. HUD loans take much longer, and private or bridge lenders can close in a few weeks. The appraisal and the other third-party reports usually set the pace, so order them as early as the lender allows.
Can you refinance a commercial property before the loan matures?
Yes, but check the prepayment terms first. Many commercial loans charge a penalty for early payoff, and on fixed-rate loans with yield maintenance or defeasance the cost can be large. Many loans also have an open period in the last few months when you can pay off without a penalty.
What happens if the property does not qualify for a big enough loan?
You have a few options: bring cash to cover the gap, ask the current lender for an extension or a modification, raise income before you apply, add a second layer of financing, or use a bridge loan while you fix the property. Lenders are more flexible when you raise the problem months ahead and not weeks ahead.
Should you refinance with your current lender or a new one?
Ask both. Your current lender knows the property, may waive some reports and may reduce or drop the prepayment fee to keep the loan. A new lender may offer a larger loan, a longer term or no personal guarantee. Written quotes from each are the only way to know.
What documents do you need to refinance a commercial property?
Lenders usually ask for a current rent roll, the trailing twelve months of income and expenses, two or three years of operating statements, copies of leases, a personal financial statement, tax returns and a schedule of the real estate you own. They also want the existing loan's payoff statement and the entity documents for the borrower.
Does a commercial refinance require a new appraisal?
Almost always. The new lender needs a current value to calculate loan-to-value, and regulated lenders must follow appraisal rules. The lender orders the appraisal and you pay for it, so you cannot simply hand over an old report.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
