
What is an agency loan, and what is a bank loan?
An agency loan is an apartment loan made by a lender approved by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, two government-sponsored companies that buy or guarantee apartment mortgages. You never borrow from the agency directly. An approved lender makes the loan under the agency's rules, and usually keeps collecting your payments as the servicer. Because the rules are standard across the country, the terms are similar from lender to lender. The programs are described in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac multifamily loans.
A bank loan is made by a bank or credit union with its own depositors' money and kept on its own books. The bank sets its own rules, so terms differ from one bank to the next and can be negotiated. For apartment buildings, these two sources make a large share of all loans, and many owners qualify for both.
Agency loan vs. bank loan: side by side
| Feature | Agency loan | Bank loan |
|---|---|---|
| Loan size | Commonly about $1 million and up | Almost any size, limited by the bank's capital |
| Fixed-rate period | 5 to 30 years, often the full term | Commonly 3 to 10 years, then a reset or balloon |
| Payment schedule | Up to 30 years, interest-only periods possible | Commonly 20 to 25 years, sometimes 30 |
| Personal guarantee | Usually non-recourse with standard exceptions | Usually full recourse |
| Prepayment | Yield maintenance, defeasance or a long step-down | Short step-down or none, often negotiable |
| Property condition | Stabilized and in good repair | More open to vacancy, repairs and renovation |
| Closing costs and reserves | Higher legal costs, monthly escrows for taxes, insurance and replacements | Lower costs, fewer required escrows |
Two definitions help here. Non-recourse means the lender can take the building if the loan fails but cannot pursue your other assets, except for defined bad acts such as fraud or misuse of rents. Stabilized means the building is mostly occupied, commonly about 90% for the prior 90 days, with no major repairs outstanding. See recourse vs. non-recourse loans.
When is an agency loan the better choice?
- You plan to hold the building a long time. A rate fixed for ten years or more removes the risk of a reset.
- You want no personal guarantee. Your home and other properties stay outside the loan.
- You want the largest loan the income supports. A 30-year schedule and possible interest-only years lower the payment, so the same income carries more debt.
- The building is full and in good shape. It fits the rules and earns the program's best terms.
- You may sell to a buyer who wants the loan. Agency loans can usually be assumed by a qualified buyer with the lender's approval and a fee.
- You may want more money later. A supplemental loan, a second loan from the same program, is often possible after a period of ownership.
Agency lenders also qualify you. They commonly look for net worth at least equal to the loan amount, liquid assets equal to roughly nine to twelve months of payments, and some experience owning apartments or a professional manager. First-time buyers often need an experienced partner.
When is a bank loan the better choice?
- The loan is under about $1 million. Most agency programs start around that size.
- The building is not stabilized. Vacant units, below-market rents or a renovation plan fit a bank far better.
- You may sell or refinance within a few years. A bank's step-down penalty is small and predictable next to yield maintenance.
- You need renovation money. A bank can add a construction draw or a line of credit to the mortgage.
- Your finances do not fit the program. A bank can weigh deposits, other business and local reputation.
- You want to change the property. Adding units, releasing land or adding a partner is a conversation with your banker, not a formal request to a loan servicer.
The price is a personal guarantee, a shorter fixed period, and usually a 20 to 25 year payment schedule that raises the payment. The bank will also expect the property's operating accounts. For smaller buildings the bank route is covered in how to finance a 5 to 20 unit apartment building.
A worked example: the same building, two loans
Here is a hypothetical case with round numbers. A stabilized 40-unit building is worth $6,000,000 and produces net operating income (NOI, income after operating expenses and before loan payments) of $420,000. Both lenders allow 75% loan-to-value and require a debt service coverage ratio of 1.25x, meaning NOI must be at least 1.25 times the yearly payments. Assume the same interest rate on both loans so that only the payment schedule differs.
- Loan-to-value limit. $6,000,000 x 0.75 = $4,500,000 from either lender.
- Agency loan, 30-year schedule. Payments on $4,500,000 are about $324,000 a year. Coverage: $420,000 / $324,000 = 1.30x. The full $4,500,000 passes.
- Bank loan, 25-year schedule. Payments on $4,500,000 are about $348,000 a year. Coverage: $420,000 / $348,000 = 1.21x. That is below 1.25x.
- Bank loan after the cut. The largest payment allowed is $420,000 / 1.25 = $336,000. The loan that fits is $4,500,000 x ($336,000 / $348,000), about $4,340,000, or 72% of value.
- Difference. The agency loan provides about $160,000 more, and its yearly payment on the same loan amount is $24,000 lower.
The bank loan has its own advantage in this example: the faster schedule pays the balance down sooner, and you could sell in year four for a modest fee. The agency loan gives more proceeds, lower payments and no guarantee, in exchange for staying put. The sizing method is in how to size a commercial loan and the effect of the payment schedule is in interest-only and amortization.
How different are the prepayment rules?
This is the difference borrowers most often underestimate. A fixed-rate agency loan is funded by investors who were promised a stream of interest, and the prepayment terms protect that promise.
- Yield maintenance: you pay a fee that makes up the interest the investor loses if rates are lower when you pay off. If rates have fallen a lot and many years remain, the fee can be very large. If rates have risen, it is usually a small minimum.
- Defeasance: you replace the loan's collateral with government securities that make the remaining payments. The cost follows the same logic as yield maintenance, plus transaction fees.
- Step-down: a set percentage of the balance that falls each year, for example 5%, 4%, 3%, 2%, 1%. This is the usual bank method, and some agency loans offer a version of it for a higher rate.
- Open period: the final months of the loan, when you can pay off with little or no penalty.
The practical rule: match the fixed-rate period to how long you expect to own the building. Taking a ten-year agency loan on a building you intend to sell in three years can erase the benefit of the lower payment, unless the buyer assumes the loan. Details are in commercial loan prepayment penalties.
How do you decide between the two?
Answer these questions in order. The first one that points clearly one way usually settles it:
- Is the loan about $1 million or more? If not, go to banks and credit unions.
- Is the building stabilized? If not, use a bank or a bridge loan now and consider an agency loan after the work is done.
- How long will you hold? Under five years favors a bank. Seven years or more favors an agency loan.
- How much does a personal guarantee matter to you? If avoiding one is a priority, agency is the main route.
- Do you need the highest loan amount? The 30-year schedule and interest-only options favor agency.
- Do you meet the agency borrower tests? Check net worth, liquidity and experience before you apply.
When the answers are mixed, get a quote from each. An agency lender and one or two banks can each give you terms from the same package within a week or two, and the comparison in writing is clearer than any rule. Which lenders sell the most agency loans is covered in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac apartment lenders.
Where CREaiD helps you compare
CREaiD is a lender search built on public loan records. In Find Lenders you pick the state, apartment loans and the loan amount, then narrow to a county, to purchase or refinance, and to the size of the building, and see the lenders that made that kind of loan there, banks and agency lenders alike. The deal check shows loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield for the numbers you type in and points out what is weak, which tells you quickly whether the building fits an agency loan. It has a free version.
Program rules and bank terms differ by lender and by deal, so confirm every term in writing with the lender and review the loan documents with your own counsel.
Key takeaways
- Agency loans give long fixed rates, 30-year payment schedules and usually no personal guarantee on stabilized buildings.
- Bank loans are more flexible, fit smaller and unfinished buildings, and are cheaper to pay off early.
- A longer payment schedule lowers the payment, so an agency loan can be larger on the same income.
- Agency prepayment terms can be expensive, so match the fixed period to how long you will own the building.
- For a stabilized building with a loan of about $1 million or more, get a written quote from each.
Questions people ask
What is the minimum loan size for an agency apartment loan?
Most agency programs start at about $1 million, and both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have programs aimed at smaller loans above that level. Below it, banks and credit unions are the usual lenders. The exact minimum depends on the lender and the market.
Are agency loan rates lower than bank rates?
Sometimes, especially for long fixed periods, where banks often do not compete. For a short fixed period a bank may match or beat an agency quote. Compare offers with the same fixed period and include fees, escrows and prepayment terms.
Can a first-time investor get a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan?
It is possible but harder. Agency lenders commonly want apartment ownership experience, so first-time buyers often bring in an experienced partner as a key principal or hire a professional manager, and still need the net worth and liquidity. Banks are usually the easier first lender.
How long does an agency loan take to close compared with a bank loan?
Both commonly take 45 to 90 days. Agency loans involve more standardized steps and legal work, while a bank that knows you can sometimes move faster. In both cases the appraisal and other reports set much of the pace.
Is a bank apartment loan always recourse?
Usually, but not always. Strong borrowers with low loan-to-value sometimes negotiate a partial guarantee or one that falls away when the building reaches certain targets. Ask for this early, before the term sheet is final.
Can you refinance a bank loan into an agency loan later?
Yes, and many owners do. A common path is a bank or bridge loan to buy and improve the building, then an agency loan once it has been stabilized for a few months. Check the bank loan's prepayment terms so the move is not costly.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
