
What are the 1031 deadlines, and why do they matter for the loan?
A 1031 exchange lets you defer capital gains tax when you sell investment or business real estate and buy other real estate of like kind, if you follow the rules. The sale proceeds go to a qualified intermediary, an independent company that holds the money so you never take possession of it, and then sends it to the closing of the replacement property.
Two deadlines start on the day the sale of the old property closes:
- Day 45. You must identify replacement properties in writing. The most common rule allows up to three properties of any value.
- Day 180. You must close on a replacement property. The limit can be shorter if your tax return for the year of the sale comes due first and you do not extend it.
The two periods run at the same time, not one after the other, and they are not extended for weekends, holidays or a slow lender. A commercial loan has its own clock: application, appraisal, environmental report, underwriting, approval and documents. If the loan clock runs past day 180, the exchange fails and the tax comes due. That is why loan timing is the center of exchange planning.
How long does the loan take, compared with the exchange window?
Closing times vary by lender type. The ranges below are common, counted from a complete application.
| Lender type | Common time to close | Fit for an exchange |
|---|---|---|
| Private or hard money lender | 1 to 3 weeks | Fast rescue option, higher cost |
| Bridge lender (debt fund) | 3 to 6 weeks | Good when time is short or the property is not stabilized |
| Bank or credit union | 45 to 75 days | Works when started early |
| Agency lender (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac) | 45 to 75 days | Works for apartments when started early |
| Life company or CMBS | 60 to 90 days | Needs an early start and a firm contract |
| SBA or HUD | Often 90 days or much longer | Risky inside a 180-day window |
The third-party reports usually set the pace. An appraisal can take three to five weeks, and an environmental report that finds a problem can add weeks more. More detail is in how long it takes to close a commercial real estate loan and appraisals, environmental reports and other third-party reports.
A worked example: the timeline
Say your sale closes on day 0 and your lender needs 60 days from a signed purchase contract and a complete application.
- Day 0. Sale closes. Proceeds go to the qualified intermediary.
- Day 40. You sign a contract on the replacement property and submit the loan application the same week.
- Day 45. You deliver your written identification, listing this property and two backups.
- Day 100. The loan closes, 60 days after the contract. You have 80 days of cushion.
Now add trouble. The appraisal runs late and the loan takes 80 days: closing moves to day 120, still safe. But suppose the first deal dies on day 90 after a bad inspection. You turn to a backup property. A 60-day loan started on day 95 closes on day 155, leaving 25 days. If you do not get a contract signed and an application in by about day 120, a 60-day lender cannot reach day 180 at all.
The lesson is in the arithmetic: 180 minus the lender's closing time is your last possible start date, and a second attempt needs room too. Signing the replacement contract before the old property closes, or within the first few weeks, is what makes a bank or agency loan realistic.
How much do you need to borrow to defer all the tax?
To defer the full gain, the general rules are that you buy replacement property worth at least as much as the property you sold, reinvest all of the net cash proceeds, and replace the debt that was paid off, either with new debt or with additional cash of your own. Value you do not replace is called boot and is generally taxable. Cash you take out is cash boot. Debt you do not replace, and do not offset with new cash, is often called mortgage boot. A worked example with round numbers:
- You sell a building for $3,000,000.
- The old loan of $1,200,000 is paid off at closing.
- Selling costs are $100,000.
- Net proceeds held by the intermediary: $3,000,000 minus $1,200,000 minus $100,000 is $1,700,000.
Trading up. You buy a replacement for $4,000,000. The $1,700,000 goes in as the down payment and you need a loan of $2,300,000, which is 57.5% of the price. You bought more than you sold, used all the proceeds and replaced more than the old debt. If the lender's coverage test supports only $2,000,000, you must add $300,000 of your own cash. Adding cash is allowed. Taking cash out is what creates boot.
Trading down. You buy for $2,600,000 instead. The $1,700,000 goes in and you borrow $900,000. You have bought $400,000 less than you sold, and that difference is generally exposed to tax even though the intermediary sent every dollar to closing.
Size the loan before you identify. If the property's income will not support the debt you need, you want to know that in week two, not week ten. The method is in how to size a commercial loan and how much down payment you need for a commercial property.
What do lenders need to know about the exchange?
Tell the lender on the first call that the purchase is part of an exchange. Experienced lenders handle exchanges all the time, and telling them late causes avoidable delays.
- Same taxpayer. The party that sold the old property generally must be the party that buys the new one. If your lender wants a new single-purpose entity as borrower, ask your tax advisor how to structure it, commonly with a single-member LLC that is disregarded for tax purposes.
- Source of the down payment. The lender will want the exchange agreement, the closing statement from the sale and a statement from the intermediary showing the funds on deposit.
- Assignment of the contract. The purchase contract is assigned to the intermediary for the exchange. Lenders and title companies are used to this, but the contract should allow it.
- Deadline in writing. Give the lender your day 180 date and ask it to confirm it can close with a cushion. Put the date in the term sheet or the application if you can.
- Loan costs. Paying loan fees and lender reserves out of exchange funds may create taxable boot. Many exchangers pay those items with separate cash. Ask your advisor before closing statements are drafted.
- Guarantor finances. Your cash is locked at the intermediary, so show other liquidity for the lender's reserve requirements.
A complete, organized submission saves the most time. Prepare the items in the commercial loan request package while the old property is still under contract, so the application goes out the day the new contract is signed.
A step-by-step plan for timing the loan
- Before listing or during the sale contract: engage a qualified intermediary and a tax advisor, and work out the minimum purchase price and debt you need.
- While the sale is pending: talk to two or three lenders, gather your financial documents and get a rough loan size for the kind of property you plan to buy.
- Before the sale closes if possible: tour replacement properties and negotiate a contract with enough due diligence time and a closing date well inside day 180.
- Contract signed: apply at once, pay for third-party reports the same day and send the lender your deadline.
- By day 45: identify the property under contract plus backups you would really buy and could really finance.
- Weekly after that: check the status of the appraisal, environmental report, title and approval. Do not wait for the lender to call.
- By about day 120: if the loan is not approved, activate the backup plan.
What if the loan is not going to close in time?
Have these options ready before you need them:
- A bridge or private loan. A fast, short-term loan closes the purchase inside the window, and you refinance into permanent debt afterward. It costs more, but usually far less than the tax. See commercial bridge loans explained.
- A second lender in parallel. On a tight timeline, some borrowers run a backup lender through early underwriting.
- More cash, smaller loan. A lower loan amount can speed approval, as long as you still replace the value and debt you need or add cash.
- Seller financing. A seller who carries a note can close on your schedule.
- A backup property. One of your identified alternates may be easier to finance.
- A contract extension. This helps only if the new closing date is still inside day 180.
A reverse exchange, where you buy the replacement before selling the old property, is another route, but the property is held by a special holding entity during the exchange, and many lenders will not lend into that structure. Ask lenders about it before you commit.
Exchange rules are tax law and the details depend on your facts, so confirm the structure with your qualified intermediary and tax advisor, and the loan terms with the lender and your own counsel.
Where CREaiD helps
When the clock is running, a short list of the right lenders matters. CREaiD's lender search shows lenders that made the kind of loan you need in your state at your loan amount, based on public loan records. The deal check shows loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield for a replacement property in a few minutes, so you can test whether it supports the debt you need before you identify it.
Key takeaways
- The 45-day and 180-day periods start when the old property's sale closes, run together and do not move for a slow loan.
- Subtract your lender's closing time from 180 to find the last day you can start, and leave room for a second attempt.
- To defer all the gain, buy equal or greater value, reinvest all proceeds and replace the old debt with new debt or added cash.
- Tell the lender about the exchange on the first call and give it the deadline in writing.
- Keep a bridge lender, a backup property or seller financing ready in case the first loan runs late.
Questions people ask
Can I get a loan on a 1031 exchange replacement property?
Yes. Most exchange purchases are financed, and lenders treat the exchange proceeds as your down payment. The lender will ask for the exchange agreement and proof of the funds held by the qualified intermediary.
Do I have to take on the same amount of debt in a 1031 exchange?
To defer all of the gain, you generally need to replace the debt that was paid off on the old property, with new debt or with additional cash of your own. Borrowing less without adding cash usually means buying less, and the shortfall is generally taxable. Confirm your numbers with a tax advisor.
When should I start talking to lenders in a 1031 exchange?
Before the sale of your old property closes. Early conversations give you a loan size, a document list and a realistic closing time before the 180-day clock starts. The formal application goes in as soon as you have a signed contract on the replacement.
What happens if my loan does not close by day 180?
The exchange fails for that property, and the sale becomes taxable. The intermediary returns the funds to you under the terms of the exchange agreement. This is why borrowers keep a fast bridge or private lender available as a backup.
Can I use exchange funds to pay loan fees and closing costs?
Some closing costs are commonly treated as exchange expenses, but loan-related costs such as lender fees and reserves may be treated as taxable boot if paid from exchange funds. Many exchangers pay those from separate cash. Ask your tax advisor before closing.
Can I refinance and pull cash out after a 1031 exchange?
Borrowers do refinance replacement properties later, but a cash-out refinance arranged too close to the exchange can draw tax scrutiny. There is no simple safe waiting period to rely on. Get advice from your tax advisor on timing before you plan it.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
