
Which reports do commercial lenders order?
Third-party reports are written by outside professionals who have no stake in the deal. The lender relies on them to confirm what the borrower and the seller have said. The usual set looks like this:
| Report | Question it answers | Typical time |
|---|---|---|
| Appraisal | What is the property worth? | About 2 to 4 weeks |
| Phase I environmental site assessment | Is contamination likely on or near the site? | About 2 to 3 weeks |
| Property condition assessment | What needs repair now and over the loan term? | About 2 to 3 weeks |
| Title commitment | Who owns it, and what liens and easements exist? | About 1 to 2 weeks |
| Survey | Where are the boundaries, buildings and easements? | About 2 to 4 weeks |
| Zoning report | Is the current use legal, and could it be rebuilt? | About 1 to 3 weeks |
| Flood zone determination | Is the building in a flood hazard area? | A few days |
Not every loan needs every report. A small bank loan may need only an appraisal, an environmental screen, title work and a flood check. Agency, CMBS, HUD and larger bank loans usually require the full set. Some properties need more: a seismic report in earthquake areas, a construction cost review on a construction loan, or a market study for some HUD loans.
How does a commercial appraisal work?
The appraisal sets the value the lender uses for loan-to-value (LTV), the loan divided by the value. On a purchase, the lender uses the lower of the price and the appraised value. Federally regulated lenders must order the appraisal themselves, so a report you ordered on your own usually cannot be used.
An appraiser uses up to three approaches and then reconciles them:
- Income approach. Value is based on what the property earns. The appraiser estimates net operating income and divides it by a capitalization rate taken from sales of similar properties. This approach carries the most weight for rented property. See cap rates and how lenders use them.
- Sales comparison approach. Value is based on recent sales of similar properties, adjusted for differences.
- Cost approach. Value is the land plus the cost to rebuild the improvements, minus depreciation. It matters most for new and special-purpose buildings.
Pay attention to which value the report gives. As-is value is the property in its present state. As-stabilized value assumes it reaches normal occupancy. As-completed value assumes planned construction is finished. Permanent lenders lend on as-is value. Bridge and construction lenders look at the future values too, which ties into LTV vs. LTC.
What is a Phase I environmental report?
A Phase I environmental site assessment is a records and site review. The consultant studies the history of the site and its neighbors, searches government databases, walks the property and interviews people who know it. No soil or water is tested. The aim is to identify recognized environmental conditions, which are signs that contamination is present or likely.
Common triggers are a current or former gas station, dry cleaner, auto repair shop or industrial use on the site or next door, and old underground storage tanks. Lenders care because cleanup costs can exceed the property's value, and because an owner can be liable for contamination someone else caused.
- Clean Phase I: no further action. This is the usual outcome.
- Recognized condition found: the lender commonly requires a Phase II, where soil, groundwater or vapor is sampled and tested. That adds weeks and cost.
- Contamination confirmed: the choices are cleanup, a holdback of funds, environmental insurance, a price reduction or walking away.
- Small or low-risk loans: some lenders start with a cheaper database screen or questionnaire and order a full Phase I only if something turns up.
Older buildings may also get an asbestos, lead paint or radon review, usually leading to an operations and maintenance plan and not to cleanup.
What do the property condition, survey and zoning reports cover?
The remaining reports each look at one risk: the building, the ownership record, the land or the rules.
- Property condition assessment (PCA). An engineer inspects the roof, structure, parking, plumbing, electrical, heating and cooling. The report lists immediate repairs (safety items and deferred maintenance) and estimates replacement reserves, the cost of replacing major components over the loan term.
- Title commitment. The title company's promise to insure the lender's lien, with a list of exceptions: existing liens, easements, restrictions and unpaid taxes. Problems on the list must be cleared or accepted before closing.
- Survey. A drawing of boundaries, buildings, easements, encroachments and access. Larger loans commonly need a detailed survey made to national title standards. An existing survey can sometimes be updated.
- Zoning report. Confirms the zoning district, whether the current use and building comply, and whether there are open violations. A building that is legal but no longer matches current rules is called legal nonconforming, and the lender will ask whether it could be rebuilt after a fire.
- Flood determination. If the building sits in a special flood hazard area, the lender requires flood insurance.
- Seismic report. In earthquake-prone areas, an engineer estimates the probable loss from a major quake. A high figure can require earthquake insurance or retrofit work.
A worked example: how report findings change a loan
Say you are buying an apartment building for $4,000,000. The lender's term sheet offers 75% LTV, so you expect a $3,000,000 loan and $1,000,000 down. Then the reports arrive.
- The appraisal comes in at $3,800,000. The lender uses the lower figure. 75% of $3,800,000 is $2,850,000. The loan is $150,000 smaller than planned.
- The property condition assessment lists $80,000 of immediate repairs. The lender requires an escrow of 125% of that estimate, a common approach. 125% of $80,000 is $100,000, held at closing and released as the work is finished.
- Total extra cash at closing: $150,000 + $100,000 = $250,000.
You now have choices. You can bring the extra $250,000. You can ask the seller to reduce the price toward the appraised value or to credit the repairs. You can ask the lender to review the appraisal if you have better comparable sales, or try a different lender. What you cannot do is wait: these findings usually arrive close to the end of the due diligence period in the purchase contract.
The reports themselves also cost money. As a hypothetical budget: appraisal $5,000, Phase I $2,500, property condition assessment $3,000, survey $5,000 and zoning report $1,000. That is $16,500 in total, or 0.55% of a $3,000,000 loan. Actual prices vary widely with property size, type and location, so ask the lender for an estimate. See commercial loan closing costs and fees.
Who orders the reports, who pays and when?
- The lender orders, the borrower pays. You usually pay a deposit when you sign the term sheet, and the lender engages vendors from its approved list.
- The reports belong to the lender. You normally receive copies, but the lender decides what it shares, so ask at the start.
- The deposit is usually not refundable once reports are ordered, even if the loan does not close.
- Reports run at the same time, so the slowest one sets the schedule. That is usually the appraisal or the survey.
- Old reports can sometimes be reused. A lender may accept a recent report if the consultant updates it and addresses it to the lender. Environmental reports go stale fastest, commonly within about six months to a year.
The reports are the main reason a loan takes as long as it does. The full schedule is in how long it takes to close a commercial real estate loan.
How to prepare so the reports help you
Consultants work from what they are given and what they can see. Seven steps improve both.
- Give the appraiser good data on the first day: current rent roll, trailing twelve months of income and expenses, a list of recent capital improvements with costs, and any comparable sales or leases you know of. See how lenders read a rent roll and a T-12.
- Hand over what already exists: prior environmental reports, surveys, title policies, roof warranties and permits.
- Arrange access. Tell tenants and the property manager that inspectors are coming, and make sure every unit, roof and mechanical room can be opened.
- Fix small things before the inspection. Trip hazards, missing smoke detectors and obvious leaks all end up on the immediate repairs list at a consultant's price.
- Research the site's history before you make an offer. If a gas station or dry cleaner once stood there, raise it with lenders up front.
- Read every report when it arrives, not at the closing table. Errors in rents, unit counts or square footage can be corrected if you catch them early.
- Line up your purchase contract dates so the due diligence period lasts longer than the reports take.
Where CREaiD helps
You cannot control what an appraiser concludes, but you can test the deal beforehand. CREaiD's deal check lets you type the value, the loan, the income and the rate and see loan-to-value, debt coverage and debt yield, and what is weak. Try a value 5% or 10% lower and see whether the loan still works. The lender search shows lenders that made that kind of loan in your state, so you can ask each one which reports it requires. It has a free version.
Report requirements differ by lender, loan program and property, so confirm the list, the cost and the timing in writing with the lender, and have your own counsel review title, survey and environmental findings.
Key takeaways
- Lenders order independent reports on value, environmental risk, physical condition, title, survey and zoning, and the borrower pays.
- Most reports take two to four weeks and run at the same time, so the slowest one sets the closing schedule.
- A low appraisal cuts the loan, because the lender uses the lower of the price and the appraised value.
- Repair findings usually become an escrow at closing, and environmental findings can lead to testing that adds weeks.
- Good data for the appraiser, prior reports and easy site access are the cheapest ways to avoid surprises.
Questions people ask
How much does a commercial appraisal cost?
Commonly a few thousand dollars for a standard property, and more for large, complex or unusual ones. The price depends on property type, size, location and how fast the lender needs it. The lender orders it and passes the cost to you, so ask for the estimate before you pay the deposit.
Can you use your own appraisal for a commercial loan?
Usually not. Federally regulated lenders must engage the appraiser themselves, and most other lenders follow the same practice. An appraisal you already have can still help you set expectations and give the new appraiser useful data.
What happens if the appraisal comes in low on a commercial property?
The lender bases the loan on the lower value, so the loan shrinks and you need more cash. You can renegotiate the price, bring more equity, ask the lender to reconsider with better comparable sales, or try another lender. On a purchase, check whether your contract lets you cancel.
Is a Phase I environmental report always required?
Not always, but it is standard on most commercial loans of meaningful size. Some lenders use a simpler database screen for small or low-risk loans and order a full Phase I only if the screen raises a question. Even when a lender does not require one, a buyer may want it for liability protection.
What is the difference between a Phase I and a Phase II environmental report?
A Phase I is a review of records, history and a site visit, with no sampling. A Phase II is ordered when the Phase I finds signs of possible contamination, and it involves testing soil, groundwater or vapor. A Phase II costs more, takes longer and can lead to cleanup requirements.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
