
The first question: how much is commercial?
Mixed-use usually means apartments above ground-floor retail or office. It can also mean office over retail, or a larger project with housing, shops and a hotel. Lenders do not have one mixed-use program. Each lender decides whether your building is closer to an apartment property or a commercial property, and that depends on the split.
They measure the split two ways: by square feet and by income. Here is the income test. Say a building has 10 apartments renting for $2,000 a month each, or $240,000 a year, and two ground-floor shops paying $80,000 a year together. Total income is $320,000. The commercial share is $80,000 divided by $320,000, or 25%.
Work out both shares before you talk to anyone. They decide which lenders can look at the deal, and they are among the first things a lender will ask.
Who lends on mixed-use
| Lender or program | When it fits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac | Mostly residential, limited commercial | Caps on commercial space and income |
| HUD/FHA multifamily | Mostly residential, long-term hold | Commercial limits, long process |
| Banks and credit unions | Almost any split, small to mid-size | Recourse, shorter terms |
| CMBS lenders | Stabilized, larger loans, any split | Reserves for the commercial leases |
| SBA lenders | Your business occupies the commercial space | Owner-occupancy requirement |
| Bridge and private lenders | Vacant retail, renovation, lease-up | Higher cost, short term |
The agency programs offer some of the best terms in commercial lending, so it is worth checking whether your building fits. Each program sets its own limit on how much of the space and the income can be commercial, and the limits are tighter in some programs than others. Ask an agency lender for the current rule before you assume the deal qualifies. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac multifamily loans explained and HUD multifamily loans explained cover those programs.
For the many small mixed-use buildings on main streets, a local bank or credit union is the most common lender. They know the street, they can underwrite a local shop tenant, and they are comfortable with small loans. See how to find a lender for a small-balance commercial loan.
How lenders underwrite the two parts
A lender splits the building in two and applies different assumptions to each side.
- Residential side. One-year leases, many tenants, quick re-leasing. The lender uses a market vacancy factor, commonly around 5% in a healthy market, and standard apartment expenses and reserves.
- Commercial side. Fewer tenants, longer leases, slower and more costly re-leasing. The lender uses a higher vacancy factor, reads each lease, checks who pays taxes and maintenance, and deducts an allowance for tenant improvements and leasing commissions.
Continue the example. On $240,000 of apartment income, a 5% vacancy factor removes $12,000. On $80,000 of retail income, a 10% factor removes $8,000. Effective gross income is $320,000 less $20,000, or $300,000. Expenses and reserves come off next, and the result is the lender's net operating income. The lender does this even if the building is full today.
The appraiser does the same thing with value, often using one cap rate for the apartments and a higher one for the retail. So a dollar of retail income usually supports less loan than a dollar of apartment income. How lenders calculate NOI explains the adjustments in detail, and how lenders read a rent roll and a T-12 shows what they check on your statements.
Some lenders run a stress test: does the building cover its loan payment if the commercial space is empty? If the apartments alone can carry the debt, the deal is far easier to approve.
Loan options and typical terms
- Agency or HUD multifamily loan. Long-term, non-recourse, with the longest amortization. Available only when the commercial share is within the program's limit.
- Bank or credit union loan. Typically a five to ten year term with a longer amortization and a personal guarantee. Works for nearly any split.
- CMBS loan. Fixed-rate and non-recourse for stabilized buildings, with reserves tied to the commercial leases.
- SBA 504 or 7(a). If your business occupies at least 51% of an existing building, the SBA can finance it, and you can rent out the remaining space. This suits a restaurant, shop or practice with apartments above only when the business uses the larger part.
- Bridge loan. For a building with a vacant storefront, units that need renovation, or a conversion in progress.
Terms land between pure multifamily and pure commercial. The closer the building is to all-residential, the closer the loan amount and coverage requirement come to apartment terms, where lenders commonly want a DSCR of about 1.20x to 1.25x. A building with a heavy commercial share is sized more like retail or office, with higher coverage and a lower loan-to-value.
What makes mixed-use easier or harder to finance
Easier:
- Commercial income is a small share, and the apartments cover the debt on their own.
- Commercial tenants are established, on leases with years remaining, and serve the neighborhood: a cafe, a pharmacy, a dentist.
- Utilities are separately metered for each unit and each commercial space.
- Residential and commercial tenants have separate entrances.
- The location has foot traffic and other active storefronts.
Harder:
- A vacant storefront, or a storefront that has turned over several times.
- One commercial tenant paying a large share of the total income.
- A use that brings noise, odors or environmental questions, such as a bar, a dry cleaner or an auto shop under apartments.
- A commercial tenant that is your own business, which lenders underwrite by looking at the business itself.
- Zoning or parking problems that limit how the commercial space can be re-leased.
- A very small building, where one vacancy moves the numbers a lot.
If your storefront is vacant, decide whether to lease it before you refinance. A signed lease with a real tenant usually adds more to the loan amount than it costs in free rent or improvements. If you cannot wait, ask lenders to size the loan on the apartments and treat the storefront as upside.
Where CREaiD fits
With mixed-use, the numbers decide which lenders are open to you, so it helps to see them clearly first. In CREaiD you can upload your deal data for a quick investment analysis, then use the Lender Matchmaker to describe the deal and get lenders that fit from a database of 1,500+ commercial real estate lenders, including banks, credit unions, agency lenders and private lenders.
Program limits and lender policies change, so confirm the terms with the lender and your own counsel before you rely on them.
Key takeaways
- Lenders classify a mixed-use building by how much of its space and income is commercial.
- A mostly residential building may qualify for Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or HUD loans, within each program's commercial limits.
- The residential and commercial parts are underwritten separately, and commercial income supports less loan per dollar.
- If the apartments alone can cover the loan payment, the deal is much easier to finance.
Questions people ask
Is a mixed-use building a residential or a commercial loan?
A building with five or more apartments plus commercial space is financed with a commercial loan either way. What changes is the program: mostly residential buildings can use multifamily programs, and buildings with a large commercial share go to banks, CMBS or private lenders.
Can I get a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan on a building with retail on the ground floor?
Often, if the retail is a small part of the building. Both set limits on the share of space and income that can be commercial. Ask an agency lender to check your building against the current limit.
What if I run my own business in the commercial space?
Then the lender will want your business's financial statements, because your business is the tenant. If the business occupies at least 51% of the building, an SBA loan may be an option. If it occupies less, expect a bank loan with a guarantee.
Do lenders count rent from a vacant storefront at market rate?
Permanent lenders generally do not. They size the loan on leases in place and may reduce even that with a vacancy factor. Bridge lenders will give credit for future rent as part of a business plan, at a higher cost.
Why did the appraisal value my retail space lower than my apartments?
Appraisers often apply a higher cap rate to the commercial income, because it carries more leasing risk. A higher cap rate on the same income gives a lower value. That is normal for mixed-use and is one reason loan amounts come in below an owner's estimate.
CREaiD shows the lenders that really made your kind of loan in your state, from public loan records.
